Member Reviews

Such a fun page turner! I love the mix of humor and wit that’s sets a great example for young readers on self awareness and individuality. I think this is an excellent book for early chapter book readers and it looks like there are more in the series! Definitely a new classic series to introduce to readers who love some other classics with string young women main characters!

Was this review helpful?

Loved it from the moment Cilla's Ye Ye found a solution to her fear of monsters! Such a sweet scene. This book will make a great addition to our collection that serves students from all around the world, many coming from bicultural families. Cilla's dad and family are Chinese - an extra bonus for my students here in Asia - and her best friend Colleen is African-American (judging by the illustrations). I appreciate how gentle and sensitive, yet very honest, issues bicultural children have to deal with are introduced: responses and reactions to their cultural background and physical appearance, tensions between the two sides of the families, - without ever sounding patronizing but rather reassuring young readers who find themselves in similar situations.

My only wondering regards Cilla's voice - almost too wise and grown up than would be expected of a kid her age - and connected to this, the text level and length of the book. Considering that the protagonist is in second grade, I would look for the prime reading audience in this grade; however, I think many second graders might still find the book a bit too challenging for independent reading; older students might find the look of it too young. Nevertheless all in all a wonderful book that I am looking forward to sharing with my students.

"GLOSSARY: CILLA’S GUIDE TO LIFE AND LITERARY TERMS" at the end of the book is pretty cute too!

Was this review helpful?

Fans of unique individuals such as Junie B. Jones will be delighted with Cilla Lee-Jenkins. As a second-grader, Cilla is more mature than Junie, and as a future author extraordinaire, she has a wonderful vocabulary. Cilla enjoys being an only child and is not AT ALL excited about a new sister on the way. She decides that the best thing to do is finish writing her bestseller and become a famous author before the baby's arrival.

Being a writer is such a big part of Cilla's life, that it comes through loud and clear in her best-seller manuscript. Even though her father urged her to give kindergarten a chance, she "despaired. As writers do." And when she plays with her dollhouse, she creates "an epic drama that had Suspense and five main characters, three love interests, ten children, two imaginary dogs, and (her) teddy bear as an all-powerful dragon." How many nine-year-olds have that sort of imagination and grasp of what creates a successful book? Yet, even with all her intelligence, she still has problems knowing the right thing to say to Colleen when she's worried over her grandmother, or how to find a way to get her own grandparents to be closer. After all, she's just a child, not yet a best-selling author.

Susan has created a completely believable character. Everything about Cilla is so easy to accept. I personally identify with Cilla's problems with her slowly growing hair when she was very young. She resents a cousin who has bows in her pigtails and explains, "When you're bald and your mom is trying to tape a bow to your head because it won't stay on, then and only then will you understand the agony of this terrible injustice." Having suffered through taped-on bows myself, I agree with Cilla completely. And I also agree with her that "your best friend knows that there's more to you than the words you accidentally say, or don't say. And you know the same thing about her."

Was this review helpful?