“For Carey, as this ridiculously enjoyable selection of his greatest hits 1986-2021 demonstrates, the reconciliation of high learning and popular reach is not a headache, but an art…From Sherlock Holmes to Germaine Greer, these reviews prove that John Carey is the finest literary critic of our age.”—Sebastian Faulks, The Sunday Times

“Surely the sharpest and wisest of our current critics - and the one who makes us laugh too.”—Claire Tomalin

“John Carey is the finest literary critic of the age, and this collection of his reviews is a calling card of his many virtues - the breadth of his interests, his incisiveness, his fearlessness, his wit, his wonderfully fierce moral vision, and above all his clarity - you may search in vain for a semi-colon - and his desire to communicate as broadly as possible. An exemplary collection from an exemplary writer.”—Andrew Holgate, Sunday Times Literary Editor

“Whether he’s discussing the appeal of Sherlock Holmes or the popularity of cannibalism in the siege of Leningrad, John Carey’s reviews are always marvels of clarity, revelation, human warmth and acerbic wit. This is literary journalism at its stylish pinnacle.”—John Walsh, Former Sunday Times Literary Editor

“Unlike the majority of his colleagues and descendants, Carey never switches code or shifts guises, speaking now as a populist, now as a specialist. He has no need to – for more than 50 years, his taut, spry, flexible, idiomatic style has enabled him to engage a large non-specialist audience without, for the most part, stinting his deep infectious belief that literature is serious, and matters.”—Leo Robson, Lead Fiction Reviewer at the New Statesman