Lakemere High’s star athlete, Jack Porter, is a master of denial. He doesn’t have an eating disorder, and his twin brother, Jared, definitely doesn’t have a drinking problem. Everything is rosy in Jack’s world–he’s headed to Duke, has his pick of the dating pool, and Lakemere are winning in their prank war with rival school, West Valley. Younger brother, Alex, is practically a genius, and Jared…he’s fine. Probably.

Then the boys’ estranged mother returns, and Jared’s drunken reaction to the news leads to a deadly run-in with their West Valley rivals. Too broken to comfort each other, the twins give in to their demons, pushing even farther apart. All Jack wants is peace, but Jared is hell-bent on revenge. As his own problems spiral, can Jack pull his head out of the sand and stop Jared before his brother's thirst for payback ends in further tragedy?