Volume #40 in this excellent anthology series. I have discovered so many new authors and/or characters through this series. Writing a short story requires excellent skills. The writer must capture the readers attention, build the story, and set the perfect reveal all in the same length as a chapter in a novel. And as always, I loved some stories more than others but I appreciate the talent displayed here. Cover art by Dan Dos Santos is so beautiful, it can take your breath away. You can recognize his work anywhere.

Another in the long line of Writers of the Future anthologies, this volume offers a selection of fantasy and sf tales that struck me as generally journeyman efforts. Which, given this is a contest for new writers, makes sense. Still, I felt that prior volumes have brought some more polished work. The contest has an excellent track record of producing fine writers and future winners of major awards, so I do not disparage its propensity for picking winners; I will follow this crew of writers in the future. I was entertained by Butter Side Down, appreciated Ashes to Ashes, Blood to Carbonfiber, and was impressed by Son, Spirit, Snake. Worth picking up.

The “Writers of the Future” Contest sponsored by Galaxy Press has been going on for, obviously, forty years now, which is why this is #40 in the series. I hadn’t picked a single one up until last year’s 39th volume, because short story collections just aren’t my thing, and the whole L. Ron Hubbard/Scientology connection STILL gives me the heebie-jeebies.

Howsomever, this time last year I was assigned to review that 39th volume for Library Journal, and learned that my hesitations on both the format and the origin notwithstanding, the collection itself was good. Damn good, in fact.

So good that when the opportunity to review this 40th volume in the series came up, I jumped at it – and was very glad that I did.

As with most collections, there were a couple of stories that just didn’t work for me, but for the most part the stories worked and worked well and I’d be thrilled to see more work from pretty much all of these award winning authors.

Which means that I have brief thoughts of a review-type and rating for each of the new individual stories, and a concluding rating that’s going to require some higher math and a bit of a fudge-factor to get into a single letter grade even with pluses and minuses available!

“The Edge of Where My Light is Cast” by Sky McKinnon
This is a story that anyone who has ever had a ‘heart cat’ – or other companion animal, one who is not merely loved but holds a singular place in one’s heart long after they are gone will find both utterly adorable and heartbreakingly sad at the same time. Tabitha was her person’s heart cat, so when Tabita went to the Rainbow Bridge her person turned her into a virtual reality cat so that they could be together for always. When her person goes ‘to the light’, Tabitha breaks all the laws of time and space and physics so that they can be together, forever in the light of the datastreams they now both call home. Grade A because there is so much dust in this one and my eyes are still tearing up.

“Son, Spirit, Snake” by Jack Nash
This one has the feel of a myth being retold as fantasy, although its an original work. It could also fit into many post-apocalyptic futures as well. A young man is dead, his mother performs the funeral rites, but the neighbors scoff and the gods do not attend as they always have. His younger brother runs in search of solace but finds only Death – but the anthropomorphization and not the event, because his mother refuses to let the gods dictate her actions a second longer – and she scares them WAY more than they scare her. Grade B because it feels like the attempt to make the myth universal sanded off a few too many of the edges that might have made it a bit more fixed in time and space – which was the intent but made it a bit more difficult to get stuck into at first.

“Nonzero” by Tom Vandermolen
As far as she knows, she’s the only survivor of her spaceship crew, out in the black in a spacesuit with no ship in sight and no chance of reaching one. She dreams of the past, while her suit’s AI does its best to awaken her to her very limited choices: whether to let her oxygen run out – and die, self-terminate using the drugs stored in her suit – and die, or take a cryogenic cocktail of drugs, let herself be put in suspended animation, and hope that the nonzero chance of survival comes through. We’ll never know. Grade A- for her snark in the face of logic and annihilation even though we’re pretty sure from the beginning that we know which path she’ll take.

“The Imagalisk” by Galen Westlake
Anyone who ever had an imaginary friend will find a bit of hope – or a light at the end of an inevitable long, dark tunnel – in this tale of an elderly man entering the hazy world of Alzheimer’s and tossed into a nursing home by his son. Only to discover that he’s been granted a marvelous gift, that for the residents of Graydon Manor the make-believe friends of their first childhoods have returned to help them ‘play’ the rest of their lives away in their second. If he can just hold only his present memory long enough to keep their gift from being stolen by a greedy former resident. Grade A- for being the saddest of sad fluff on the horns of the reader’s dilemma of whether this is one last grand caper or if this entire tale is just a product of the disease that brought him to Graydon Manor in the first place.

“Life and Death and Love in the Bayou” by Stephannie Tallent
One of two stories in the collection about magic and power and love and death and sacrifice that’s made even better because the sacrifice is willing and the love isn’t romantic. This one is haunting, not horror but definitely on the verge of it – but then again, if any place is haunted it’s the bayou country of Louisiana. Grade A- for the story and A+ for the art for this one which is beautiful.

“Five Days Until Sunset” by Lance Robinson
In spite of what a whole lot of SF would have one believe, the likelihood is that early colony ships will be a fairly iffy proposition. Which means that this reminds me a bit of Mickey7 but definitely without the humorous bits. Although in this case, it’s not that the planet is barely habitable, but rather that it’s not habitable in the way that the colonists dreamed of. It’s a story about adapting your dreams to your circumstances instead of attempting to force the circumstances to match your dreams. Grade A because the story is good and so complete in its very short length and it even manages to deal well with religion in the future which is really, really hard even in the present.

“Shaman Dreams” by S.M. Stirling
This one is new for the collection – which I wasn’t expecting. It’s also the story inspired by the gorgeous cover art. Even though this is set in the far distant past, as the last Ice Age is fading away, the story it reminds me of most and rather surprisingly a lot is The Tusks of Extinction – quite possibly crossed a bit with Jean Auel’s Clan of the Cave Bear series. Grade A+

“The Wall Isn’t a Circle” by Rosalyn Robilliard
Very SFnal, but exceedingly horrifying in its implications. It starts out as time travel – and that’s fun with interesting possibilities. The scare in this one is that it doesn’t stay there, and where it leaps to is a question of just how far – and how far over the line of morality – someone will go to get justice and where the line blurs between justice and revenge. Grade A for the wild ride of the story’s ultimate WOW.

“Da-ko-ta” by Amir Agoora
This one didn’t work for me. The bones of something really terrific are here, and I think it potentially had a lot to say about colonialism and culture erasure and just how terrible manifest destiny was but it may have just needed to be longer so that its ideas got fully on the page and weren’t merely teased out. Grade C

“Squiddy” by John Eric Schleicher
Squiddy gets its toes right up to the line of SF horror and then sticks there with tentacles. Literal, actual tentacles, in an invasion of squid-like monsters that are an addictive drug that requires sticking the squid-like creature up one’s nose. So also gross-out horror. But underneath that is a story about a drug addled dystopia, one woman who refuses to use or be used and another woman who sees her as a beacon to follow to a better, squid-free future. Grade B because this one was interesting and had a kind of wild/weird west feel but just wasn’t my jam – or calamari.

“Halo” by Nancy Kress
This is the second new-for-this-collection story by a well-known author rather than a contest winner. It’s laboratory based SF, and jumps off from the recent pandemic, but doesn’t go anywhere one thinks it will go because it’s a story about human behavior and human intelligence and the power of inspiration and how much the latter is worth saving if engineering the former can do so much ‘good’ – depending on who is determining that good. A thought-provoking Grade A story.

“Ashes to Ashes, Blood to Carbonfiber” by James Davies
There are always at least a couple of stories in any collection that don’t work for an individual reader and this was my other one. I may have been trying to read too late in the evening, or it may be that the bleakness of this particular dystopia just didn’t work for me, or the nature of the sacrifice required to break out was a bit too much even as it was talked more around than directly about. I did like that it worked out to a much better ending than I was expecting, but it just didn’t work for me. Grade C

“Summer of Thirty Years” by Lisa Silverthorne
This is the other story in the collection about sacrifice and power and love and death – done in a completely different way from the bayou story and still not about romantic love after all – although at the beginning it looks like it might be. It’s sweet and sad and haunting and beautiful, if not quite as profound as “Life and Death and Love in the Bayou” still an excellent story. Grade A-

“Butter Side Down” by Kal M
There had to be a story that managed to invoke Murderbot, and this was it. What made it fun was that the whole thing is a trial transcript, as the lone human on this particular spaceship’s crew is on trial for rescuing a planet-killing AI, falling in love with it and helping it escape. It seems like the fears of what this ultimate weapon of mass destruction – that Joe Smith has nicknamed “Breddy” can do to the whole, entire universe are very real – but that Joe is convinced that “Breddy” has decided not to. And he’s right and they’re all wrong. While the story is more lighthearted than one might imagine, in the end it’s a story about always extending the hand of friendship – and being rewarded with friendship in return to the nth degree. Grade A+

Escape Rating A- for the collection as a whole, because I mostly did escape – even in the couple of stories that weren’t quite my cuppa after all. I am still a bit surprised to say this, all things considered, but I’m honestly looking forward to getting that 41st volume in the series, this time next year.

The stories in this anthology are mind-blowing and spine-chilling. Discover the authors as they write about uncharted worlds and unlimited possibilities. The stories carried me away and the illustrations are astounding. The latest book in this annual series has something for every SF and fantasy reader, from the blackness of space to the power of magic and all of the places and planes in between. One of my favorite stories is “ Son, Spirit, Snake” by Jack Nash, art by Pedro N.. It is about no one came to his brother’s funeral, not even the spirits. Étienne knew it was his fault.— his brother had gotten a gold bracelet for his little brother’s birthday gift. His mother wants the bracelet to be able to get a month’s worth of food. Étienne with his bracelet runs away to an old mining cave and falls into a deep hole. Someone or something talks to him. Who is it? Will he escape? This was an exceptional book for me to read as I enjoyed 99% of the stories and illustrations. The authors have written fresh ideas into their stories. The talent of the upcoming authors in this volume have impressed me with there talent.

Wow, this is very long. It took me a while to get through all of the stories, so I’ve been plugging away at it. First off, kudos to all of the extremely talented illustrators who had thirty days to come up with a suitable work of art to accompany each story.

My hat’s off to all the writers as well! There are some gems in here, and I definitely have a favorite: “Ashes to Ashes, Blood to Carbonfiber” by James Davies. That one will make you cry. What would you sacrifice to right a very, very large wrong?


My honorable mentions:

”The Edge of Where My Light Is Cast” by Sky McKinnon, which is much more than a cat desperately searching for its beloved owner.

“The Imagalisk” by Galen Westlake, wherein a man in a nursing home is warned that he might have some ‘visitors’ in his room.

“Life and Death and Love in the Bayou” by Stephannie Tallent, because sometimes teens have to protect their parents, by whatever means necessary.

“Five Days Until Sunset” by Lance Robinson, where voyagers finally arrive at a new planet…but something is off. Also, where are all the other crewmembers?

“The Wall Isn’t a Circle” by Rosalyn Robilliard. Whose eyes would you look through, of anyone in history, if technology allowed it?

“Da-ko-ta” by Amir Agoora. In which Teddy Roosevelt hunts for a wendigo with the help of a justifiably angry Native American child.

“Halo” by Nancy Kress. A very intriguing story about an outbreak that is mishandled.

“Summer of Thirty Years” by Lisa Silverthorne. This one is my second favorite. Magic always comes with a price.

“Butter Side Down” by Kal M. I mean, I can’t not mention a love story featuring a toaster and a human!

This is already out, peeps! Grab a copy today!

Thank you to NetGalley and BooksGoSocial for the ebook! All opinions are mine alone.

Great short stories for those who don't like science fiction (and those who do). Stories with interesting twists. Not 'hard' science fiction, but thinking science + fiction.

Wow! What an immense concentration of talent all rolled into one short story collection. I would urge people to give this book a try as I think there's something for everyone in here. The book starts with a brief explanation on the selection process, which was informative and useful for gaining perspective. There's a lot of up and coming bright minds in this collection and it's a handy for me as a directory for exploring new writers in scifi.

The stories were each so unique to the individual authors and it was a moving experience to go from one author to the next understanding their perspective and seeing how it comes through in the stories they told.

Very good book with 12 short stories and illustrations from a variety of authors. Enjoyed the variety of plot lines and quality of illustrations.

These new writers deserve to go far.

A great collection of sci-fi stories. I was curious about what kind of stories there would be given LRH's affiliations but was pleasantly surprised to find some really good stuff in here.