Member Reviews

Our library systems offer a seed library every year. I would use this book in displays for our seed library to promote our vegetable seed packs. The book is well written and easy to understand for the novice gardener.

Was this review helpful?

Solid information and a helpful guide for starting a vegetable garden. I feel like I can reference this during planning and I also read through the Illinois guide as I live there and we always look for ways to bond. Gardening has always been fun for that especially when we have a meal made with home grown food.

Was this review helpful?

This is a good, locally/regionally focused gardening book for folks who are either new to gardening, new to gardening in Indiana, or want to get serious about vegetable gardening in the fickle landscape of Indiana. As a lifelong native to the state, I have lived in all regions of the state and know from experience how gardening differs from the northern, to the central, to the southern regions of the state. It's straightforward and easy to understand. It answers a lot of the questions about soil composition, hardiness zones, etc. and how these change throughout the state. I will buy this for my library and expect that it will circulate well.

Was this review helpful?

Grow Great Vegetables in Indiana is a regionally tailored home gardening guide for producing vegetables for taste and nutrition and to increase self-reliance and food security. This is one of a series of regionally/state specific guides released & reformatted by Timber Press. Edited by Bevin Cohen, it's due out in May 2023, runs 208 pages and will be available in paperback and ebook formats. It's based on an earlier release Vegetable Gardening in the Midwest by Michael VanderBrug, reformatted and edited for Indiana gardeners. All of the guides in this series follow the same format.

This guide is arranged by seasons with a chapter for each month. The introductory chapter (~13% of the page content) covers garden planning, climates and subzones in Indiana, as well as very general gardening advice. Worth noting that a majority of the content of the books in this series based on/edited from the same volume (in this case Vegetable Gardening in the Midwest) contain overlapping information and there are only slight differences in content and recommendations.

The monthly sections include tasks for each month, potential problems and troubleshooting, planning and placement of the garden plot, harvesting and more.

The third section of the book is a regional guide to choosing vegetables and specific varieties which will thrive in the area.

There's a resource list (slanted to readers in the Midwest), a bibliography and further reading list, USDA based hardiness zonal map, and an index. The photography is crisp, clear, and abundant. This is a well crafted book which will provide gardeners with hours of blissful dreaming as well as serving as a valuable troubleshooting guide. For readers who have the aforementioned Gardening in the Midwest, much of the content is verbatim here. For readers unfamiliar with the earlier title, there's a lot of worthwhile info.

Four stars. Very well done.

Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher for review purposes

Was this review helpful?

“They imagine gardening as something only for those born with green thumbs - some mysterious ability given only to the luckiest people. I am here to state for the record this is false. Anyone can learn to be a gardener.”

Wow! This book certainly has it all. I’ve read several intro to gardening books and can attest that this one is complete with tidbits of information not present in other books. For example I found the soil composition test very interesting and will be trying on my own soil soon.

Grow Great Vegetables Indiana is thorough without being too wordy or advanced for someone starting out in gardening. This books has everything you need to know about soul, water, sun and shade, composting, growing seasons and temperatures, tools, pests and diseases, etc. The planning section of the book has everything from garden design to crop rotation to planting methods and more.

Perhaps what I enjoyed most from this book was the month by month overview. Each month lists tasks to complete or plan out and what can be harvested. Presenting the information in this way makes it feel more manageable to a new gardener and reduces the intimidation of starting a new garden.

The last part of the book is the Edibles A to Z chart section, which shows the planting and harvesting times for all the vegetables that can be grown in the state. This would be great to print off to use as a reference sheet. Following this chart is a collection of one to two page excerpts detailing more information about each fruit or vegetable.

If you live in Indiana and want to start gardening this book is an absolute must! I’m confident even the most experienced gardeners could glean some new insight from Bevin Cohen’s Grow Great Vegetables Indiana.

Was this review helpful?

I am cutting and pasting my review since this book series cuts and pastes their content from state to state. This series is cut and pasted for all the midwest states, with just a handful of pages changed. I have read several of them cover to cover and almost all of it is absolutely identical -- the intro about what it's like to live in the state (literally, it's a whole page about how great the state is and how it’s second only to California for how great it is to garden there and what the unique strengths and challenges are and they just change the state name and leave all the same descriptions in), photos, monthly guide, etc.

I am in MN and can't speak to how accurate it is for other states but I suspect it's fairly accurate for this state. It is not entirely accurate for MN. For instance, it says to harvest asparagus in March. We're buried in snow in March. We harvest our asparagus in May, every single year. Maybe in your state you harvest your asparagus in March though and maybe it will be more accurate for your state.

This series really should have been one book, Grow Great Vegetables in the Midwest, and then added the few pages showing the maps with zones and the list of a handful of cities average frost dates that are shoehorned in. I have no idea what state the author really lives in, since it's kept deliberately very vague. All that said, it has good basic growing information for novice gardeners.

I read a temporary digital ARC of this book for review.

Was this review helpful?