No Life for a Lady by Hannah Dolby

I received an advance review copy for free thanks to NetGalley and Aria and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

Blurb

It's remarkable how men react when women break the rules... but the people of Hastings are about to discover, women can be remarkable too...

1896. At 28, Violet's father is beginning to fear she will never marry. But every suitor he puts forward, she finds an increasingly creative way of rebuffing.

Because Violet is a woman who knows her own mind – and her mind is on her mother, who went missing 10 years earlier, vanishing from Hastings Pier without a trace.

Looking for the missing is not a suitable pastime for a lady. But when Violet hires a seaside detective to help, she sets off an unexpected chain of events that will throw her life into chaos.

Can Violet solve the mystery of Lily Hamilton's vanishing? Or will trying cost her more than she can afford to lose?

My Opinion

Violet wants to find out to her mother who had disappeared 10 years earlier, she enlists the help of a local detective to discover what happened on that night. Violet is not interested in finding herself a husband much to the annoyance of her father. Whilst this was not a book I would usually have chosen, it is a highly entertaining read.

This book was one of those that while I thought I could put it down, I found myself picking it up a few minutes later to read a few more chapters. The first half of the book is slow, but the pace does pick up.

Rating 4/5

It is not bad. At first, I was really hooked and cannot wait what is going to happen next. But then, it become more boring and boring...

I like the idea, but I was under impression that alll of that was, in fact, just flat. The characters were kinda boring and I was not engaged at all into their lives.

So... there is a potential here, but for me, it was just meeeh.

3/5

No Life for a Lady is light-hearted, cosy historical mystery with a touch of romance from Hannah Dolby.

‘There are ladies who don’t like what they are made for, the cleaning and the domestic business, the caring and the mothering. We might think badly of them for it, but it does happen.’

Violet Hamilton would prefer a profession to a husband, at twenty-seven she continues to fend off the latter, much to her father’s disapproval, but is yet to find the former. In part this state of affairs stems from the sudden disappearance of her mother in 1886 when she was eighteen, and as the ten year anniversary approaches, Violet is determined to find out what happened to her.

Discretely hiring a private detective is the first step but there is something about Frank Knight and his interest in her mother that Violet finds disturbing. An advertisement discovered by chance leads her to an another private eye, and though Benjamin Blackthorn initially turns her down, Violet eventually convinces him to help.

Violet is a likeable lead character. She chafes at society’s expectations but with the naivety of a well-raised lady. This means she is caught unawares more than once, but to her credit she is rarely discouraged and persists regardless.

There are several amusing scenes, including Violet’s efforts to turn away unwanted suitors, discretely tail a gentleman with her chaperone in tow, and a picnic with unexpected nature views. I also enjoyed the banter between Violet and Benjamin. Their low key romance is a sweet feature of the novel.

The mystery surrounding Violet’s mother’s disappearance plays out well, though I felt there were some small issues with the plotting, and the pacing was a little even. I enjoyed the reveal of the villain, and the drama of the conclusion.

No Life For a Lady is an engaging read with the potential to become a series.

Violet Hamilton lost her mother 10 years ago, on the cusp of her come out. As a result she has loved in solitude and melancholy since then, vowing never to marry. She gets the idea she must find out what happens to her mother, and it leads to intrigue, new friends, and love.

His story has good bones, but the execution was painstakingly slow. Just wanted it to move on with the action and discovery.

A beach holiday has had me catching up with a set of fabulous novels which I've finally got round to reading. And enjoying!! Really enjoyed this one. Very original, a Victorian novel but with a difference and with a joyful and feisty protagonist to boot! Violet is just a dream!
There'a great writing, a great plot and a great mystery. Some oohs and ahs along the way, and definitely some laugh out loud moments.
Set in 1896, Violet is 28 and avoiding marriage for as long as she can. She has other ideas about how to spend her days, inventing rather strange charities to explain away the time she is, in reality, spending on a quite different pursuit!
Original, well written, 5* novel to get your teeth into!

Violet is no lady to the society, is she? She craves for knowledge, for freedom and for a life with no marriage. But above all she longs for her mother who was missing for a very long time. If she has enough freedom, she would search for her mother across the world. The bare minimum she could do is to hire a detective but what she gained from it is not what she expected. She wanted to know her mother whereabout but she dont want to sacrifice her reputation.
It's a light mystery with a light humor story. It's a story which discover about life alongside Violet. There's a lot of things she doesnt know because there's limited knowledge for a lady. This book doesn't focus on violet's mother case only but it revolve with side cases. I love how it has a strong hook wigtout losing its momentum to connect a mystery to another. I didn't feel bored and the hook really got me reading non stop. This story deserves praise for its clean plot, messages and character build up.
If its not for the lack of the ending I would give 5 instead of 4.5 stars. It wasn't not good but it just wasn't strong enough. But still, I live thus book!

It’s 1896 and Violet is still not married at the ripe old age of 28, her father is beside himself and worried his daughter is going to end up a dried up old shrew and it’s not for lack of trying. He’s brought multiple nice youngish men men home for her to meet but Violet’s not the marrying kind, she’s thoroughly modern woman who wants to work and make her own way but more than anything she wants to find out what happens to her beautiful charismatic mother who disappeared a decade ago. This was so much fun, Violet is fantastic and I love her so much, she’s stubborn and determined and easily distracted by hot guys doing physical labour and she’s not entirely sure why. Loved it!

I loved this refreshing debut novel from Hannah Dolby, it was a joy to read and Violet was a wonderful character!

Its 1896 and 28 year old unmarried Violet Hamilton lives with her father and runs their h0usehold - he is keen for her to settle down, but Violet wants nothing less than to be married - and puts off all possible suitors as soon as possible.
Violet is independent and wants to find her own path through life though there are societal barriers in her way. Reading about her excitement at possibly using a typewriter brought home to me just how restricted life was for single women, as well as the power that her father had to limit her world by insisting on her having a chaperone to walk around town.

Violet's mother disappeared ten years ago, and Violet is desperate to find out what happened to her. The investigation takes her to various insalubrious corners of Hastings and St Leonards, finding out more about her mother's hidden past but will she ever be able to find out the truth?

I had high hopes for this tale, but sadly, it failed to capture my imagination. I like my main characters with a little more gumption out of the gate.

This was a fun and unique historical fiction. Violet’s journey to find her own way and the truth of her mothers history spun a unique tail and will make for good beach side reading this summer!

Featuring a strong, independent female, lead, and plenty of interesting and unique historical details. This book will easily capture your imagination and sweep your way.

I really enjoyed this book. Charming, inspiring and gently humorous. At 28 Violet Hamilton is trying to find her way in the world of 1896. Her mother disappeared 10 years before leaving her with unanswered questions. Her father wants to marry her off but she is resisting as she wants to find her own way in the world. She employs a private detective to find out more about her mother’s disappearance but some of the evidence he finds leads her to question her memories of her mother and her parents’ marriage.

As the detective becomes difficult she tries to hire another one - Benjamin Blackthorn - a gentle giant who wants a quiet life selling furniture. Their lives become entwined and various mysteries are resolved.

A gentle read to be recommended.

Late 1800s is a favorite genre of mine, and this book just brings more light to a favorite time period. This book is about rebellion, especially for its time period. A decent mystery, but fun enough read, this is definitely a book to pack on your spring.summer vacay or recommend to the book club.

This book was so much fun! I think the turn of the century into the 1900s, right before the end of Queen Victoria's reign, is such an interesting time period to have for a setting, and it felt refreshing for this to be set outside of London as I feel like we rarely get a more rural Victorian perspective! Violet as a protagonist felt very relatable, despite being brought up in a society far removed from today, and I admired her determination to remain marriageless throughout, until the right person came along, and even then her priorities to become a Lady Detective remained first and foremost. No Life for a Lady did feel quite slow-paced at times, and I would've loved a bit more action compared to the constant irritations Violet faced with Mr. Knight, but overall it kept me very entertained.

Thank you NetGalley for the advance copy.

This book was better than I thought it would be. Very funny and entertaining cozy mystery with a bit of romance.

*I received a copy of this book on NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for this opportunity.*

Violet Hamilton is content with her life as it is. She is determined to live her life exactly how she desires-- mostly avoiding high society ladies, taking long strolls on the beach, and deterring any gentlemen callers her father pushes onto her. However, with the ten year anniversary of her mother's mysterious disappearance, Violet has finally decided to take the plunge and hire a detective to find sorely needed answers.

What follows is an entertaining, if slow paced, piece of fiction with a cast of characters you can't help but grow to love. While not exactly historically accurate on most accounts, NO LIFE FOR A LADY is a lighthearted read perfect for a modern audience. Violet is an engaging main character not subject to the limitations of women during her time period-- her misadventures introduce her to a wider world, and, in turn, made for a fun and twisty story.

I found this one very interesting and so difficult to my usual reading genre. A little bit quirky at times but very enjoyable. My thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for giving me the opportunity to read this book in return for an honest review.

In Hannah Dolby’s debut our heroine is delightfully clueless about sex and the like as she tries to figure out what happened to her mother who disappeared a decade earlier. This is charming as well as witty and I’m hoping that it’s going to turn out to be the first in a series. Hopefully enough people will buy it to make that happen because we have some savvy lady sleuths but not so many of the slightly bewildered by the the range of human behaviour ones and I would like more!

In the first pages of #NoLifeforaLady, Violet, its nineteenth-century twenty-something heroine, sets out to find her mother, who disappeared a decade earlier. Her determination to solve this mystery is matched only by her desire to thwart her bumbling father's attempts to marry her off. She knows how to poke fun at herself, and her self-deprecating sense of humor and naïveté propel the reader through a series of intriguing adventures. I cheered Violet on and just had to know--will she find her mother? Will she find love? The book is enhanced by its beautiful, lyrical descriptions of Violet's home, an English seaside village, and the author's deep knowledge of flora and fauna adds depth. A lovely read.

No Life for a Lady is a historical mystery set toward the end of the 19th century. Cosy crime readers will enjoy the slow pace and the transition of the protagonist from sheltered spinster to independent professional.

It’s remarkable how men react when women break the rules.

No Life for a Lady is Hannah Dolby’s first novel and has since been declared “the most joyful book of 2023”. Published in March 2023, it quickly gained critical acclaim and praise worldwide. A historical mystery, it covers a range of topics from feminism to marriage to the roles we play in society.

--------------------

Summary
The story follows Violet Hamilton, a 28-year-old woman, unmarried and all but ostracised from polite society. Her father worries that she’ll never find a husband as she continuously rebuffs every suitor, and her mother disappeared ten years previous – a mystery that Violet is adamant to solve. Hiring a so-called detective sets off a string of events that puts more than just her own reputation at risk. But she’s a woman who knows her own mind, and she refuses to give up her search for the mother who vanished without a trace. Can she finally solve the mystery of Lily Hamilton? Or will the search cost her more than she can afford to lose?

--------------------

Commentary
No Life for a Lady is a funny, adventurous story perfect to read in one sitting!

Praise
- There are numerous plot twists that keep you on your toes and completely unsure as to what will happen next. It makes the story enjoyable and entertaining as the mystery unfolds right in front of your eyes.
- It has the perfect blend of murder-mystery and social-criticism. Dolby was able to expertly weave the problems of the patriarchy and misogynism into this story without it feeling forced, leaving the reader curious and engaged in equal measure.
- It’s realistic in the sense of how society is portrayed. Characters are complexly developed, and the hero doesn’t always win. Unfortunately, this does lead to a lack of happy endings for more than one person, but seeing the harsh realities of life make the book a satisfying read despite that.

Critique
- The beginning of the book is flat and uninspiring, and admittedly, I considered giving up there and then. However, despite its rocky start, it does improve, and by the end of the story, I was fully captivated!
- Speaking of the end of the story, the so-called “resolution” comes swiftly and suddenly and isn’t entirely satisfactory. The story also ends right before you want it to, so be prepared to have follow-up questions once you’ve finished reading it.
- The protagonist of the story, Violet, is incredibly naive and does not significantly develop as a character throughout the novel. The added disadvantage is that this story is told through her eyes in the first-person narrative, and given her wide-eyed personality, it’s annoying at times to see something so blatant that Violet herself doesn’t understand.

--------------------

Recommendations
Overall, I’d give Hannah Dolby’s No Life for a Lady a three out of five. If Bridgerton met Enola Holmes, then this is what you’d get!

I’d recommend this novel to fans of period dramas or Victorian detective fiction, as it combines all of the glamour and expectations of an 1800s debutant with the gritty realism of Hercule Poirot’s whodunit. If you’re looking for a light-hearted and engaging mystery, then this is the book for you!