Member Reviews

On her death bed Marie Currie born Marya Sklodowska holds the hand of her ex fiancé Kazimierz Zorawski falls asleep dreaming of what her life might have if she ha s married Kazimierz. Half life written by Jillian Cantor I recommend readers who like historical fiction and the movie Sliding Doors to imagine what Marie’s life might have been like if she remained in Poland and married the then love of her life. Marie wonders and dreams on what her life might have been like if she decided to stay in Poland and married Kazimierz. Her dream impacts the life of her sisters with who they meet and marry and children and careers; along with the life of her partners in either life and friendships. In either reality which is similar but the partner choices are different along with the choice of career. I give four stars being a historical fiction in a bibliography style as a reader would not really know what is fictional and what is true until the end of the book.
Review run date 31 Mar 2021 for Netgalley. On 07 April 2021 my review will be posted on my Wordpress blog and Facebook blog, Amazon.com.au, goodreads, kobo, googlebooks and iBooks. My WordPress blog is http://bluefalkon95adorationofallgenres.wordpress.com My Facebook reader blog page link, is https://www.facebook.com/BlueFalkon95-Readers-blog-104660277776984
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Simon & Schuster Australia through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
#HalfLife #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Jillian Cantor Half Life Simon&Schuster 2021 (first published 2011)

Thank you NetGalley for this unproofed copy for review.

Jillian Cantor uses a familiar device – ‘sliding doors’, ‘what if?’ real and alternative lives – but that is as far as familiarity goes. What Cantor does with the device is truly captivating. The alternative stories of Marie Curie are full of characters that have an abundance of life, at the same time exploring what it means to be a woman dedicated to a range of attitudes, capacities and roles: wife, mother, career woman, widow and/or lover with experiences of loss, exhilaration, notoriety, fame and contentment.

The stories of Marya Sklodowska who takes the train to Paris to study at the Sorbonne and become Marie Curie, and the same Marya who instead marries Kazimierz Zorawski and remains in Russian Poland are developed in alternate chapters. Marya’s sisters, Bronia and Hela also have different lives as they also live their stories alongside Marie or Marya. Kazimierz becomes a major character with Marya, living frugally in Poland; in Marie’s story he marries well; Pierre Curie joins Marie in their laboratory and in winning the Nobel Prize. Minor characters are woven throughout the alternating stories, their life stories depending upon those of the main character, Marie/Marya.

Cantor explains her interest in the Marie Curie narrative as having a long history. Her interest in the character piqued long before she found the way in which she wanted to write the story. Her choice hinged on the scene that is so poignant in the fictional life – Marya does not climb aboard the train to Paris, she marries Kazimierz. However, it is the way in which the love affair between Marya and Kazimierz finishes that intrigued Cantor. His mother, for whom Marya worked as a governess to the younger children, did not think her good enough to become a family member. As Cantor says, ‘There was the fact that this amazing, brilliant woman, who would later go on to change the course of science and win two Nobel Prizes, was deemed not good enough as a young poor woman in Poland’.

Part of the charm and fascination in the novel is its settings. The status of women in Russian Poland provides the background to the ‘Flying University’ that Mayra creates. The university meets in its students’ homes with women teaching subjects with which they are familiar. Mayra, true to Marie, teaches science, she is poor at music, another class, and a profession that cleverly links with Marie’s story in Paris. The alternative story is that of an intelligent woman who must educate herself in a closed environment of Russian Poland where women are considered unworthy of education. Despite the restrictive atmosphere, the descriptions of Warsaw and Krakow are enticing.

Paris, Sweden and trips back to Poland feature in Marie’s story. But most important is the laboratory. And it is this that impacts on Marie’s relationship with her daughter – one that is at the same time understandable but also sad. In each of the stories, the attitudes towards family, children, partners, and the outside world are dealt with in detail. The women’s feelings of satisfaction and despair, Marie’s short-term desire to adopt a different approach to mothering, their relationships with others illuminate the way in which women’s choices are complex. The women are written in a way that creates empathy rather than judgment. Here, Cantor excels at using fiction to show the conflicts that feminist nonfiction works consider. There are no rules laid down, Marie Curie stands tall while Marya Zorawski, leading her different life, is also a character to be admired.

Half Life, although a scientific reference to the Curie’s Radium, seems to have more meanings within the novel. Marie’s impression of the light in her daughter’s eyes is a warmer, lighter side of the dedicated scientist. Light is a continuing theme in the Curie’s experimentation, illuminating the laboratory in the dark, and enlightening the world. At the same time, the ill health of both Curies and Marie’s death at sixty-six, with which the novel begins and ends, suggests that their work was responsible for the shortness of their lives. However, the dedication to their work, and each other, suggests that, although truncated, their lives were well lived. Cantor’s writing emphasises life, even when tragedies occur. The phrase could never be applied the lives led by Marie/Marya. Rather than half-lives, these women lived very full lives, the real one and the fictional version overlapping in some skillful writing and development of the fictional characters, in so many respects true to the real Marie Curie. The linkages between fact and fiction are deft and cleverly made. To return to my opening observation, Half Life is truly captivating.

Was this review helpful?

Thankyou to NetGalley, Simon and Schuster Australia and the author, Jillian Cantor, for the opportunity to read an advanced readers copy of Half Life in exchange for an honest and unbiased opinion.
Where do I start? This book was brilliant.
The storyline was well thought out and written. The alternate lives of Marie were blended beautifully.
Half Life was rich in description and captivating. I was hooked from the start. 4.5 stars.
Well worth the sleep deprivation. A must read.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a good read, extremely hard to put down and had me quite emotional a few times during the book.
It’s the story of Marie Curie’s life alongside the possible life she could’ve lived if Marya Sklodowska had never left Poland and married her first love, Kazimierz Zorawski. The couple were engaged but his mother didn’t approve of Marya and in real life a year or so later she leaves Poland to study in Paris.
The book is narrated in the first person, and the two streams (half lives?) alternate chapter by chapter. I thought the author did this skilfully and I was involved in the characters lives in both halves. It’s well researched and it must’ve been hard to keep the alternate life believable but it works.
The difficulties for women to study and work in these times is well explored, across time and countries. The difficulties of maintaining balance between family life and work especially for driven scientists like Curie; the sexism of the scientific community whether it be universities or even the Nobel prize (Pierre refused to accept unless Marie also got it) is astonishing but not surprising.
It is hard to read of all their experiments with radioactive materials completely unprotected without being horrified (Pierre gives Marie a radium nightlight!). It is unsurprising how much their health suffered.
An excellent, informative and emotional read.

Was this review helpful?

This book was absolutely amazing I found myself unable to put it down. Told in a sliding doors format we explore the life of Marie Curie. In alternating chapters we explore the real life of Marie Curie and the authors imagined life of Marie Curie. Cantor poses the question what would her life looked like had she made different choices along the way.
The story of Marie Curie is one of struggle and triumphs of a life lives in the pursuit of excellence often at the expense of her personal life. The imagined life of Marya is one of struggle and triumphs of a life lives in the pursuit of excellence often at the expense of her personal life. In what can only be described as brilliant writing Cantor draws you in the two lives of this one woman in a way that has you turning the pages in anticipation.
The research that must have gone into this novel is astounding as no stone in the real life of Marie Curie is left unturned. From Nobel prizes to her relationship with her husband, her lover and her children. Cantor in enviable fashion forces as to look at our lives and ask the question where would I be if I had made even just one different choice.
This novel also reminds us at a time when we as women are fighting for equality of the women who came before us and the battles they faced in the fight for equality in a much different time and space. I am not one for reading the authors notes but in this case I feel that it is must.

I was given an ARC copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review. My thanks to Netgalley the author and the publisher.

Was this review helpful?

What a brilliant plot - to simultaneously explore the real life of Marie Curie and an imagined alternative life involving the same characters. It really did feel like I was reading about two different people at the beginning, but towards the end it became more difficult to separate which storyline I was reading. Perhaps that was intentional and speaks to the way we can grow into our identity as we experience life.

Themes of possibilities, decisions, consequences and regret are interwoven with questions of class, privilege, gender and identity. We always have choices but how do our circumstances limit the scope of those choices? How does our identity impact our choices and how do our choices affect the ongoing development of our identity? What is revealed about us by the sacrifices we are willing to make? Do we ever truly know what is happening in another person's life?

Underlying the complex plot and commentary on choices and consequences were recurring threads of loss and grief, not only for the death of loved ones, but for the life that could have been had different choices been made.

I was left reflecting on the choices that are available to me as a woman in 2021, compared to the more limited choices available to women in 1891. The story has much to say about how women were legally restricted in those times, but also points out the ways in which women can still find themselves being boxed into expected roles of motherhood and marital responsibilities, being asked to make choices that are rarely asked of men.

Was this review helpful?