Thank you NetGalley for an ARC of this book! I really enjoyed it as my first DeWitt book. I really enjoyed the writing style and the growth made by both characters from teenage years to adulthood. It showcased how everyone evolves and grows in their own ways, and you can still find your way back together, maybe with a little help from Grandma ;). As someone super interested in house flipping, I would have loved to get more into the complexities of the work, not for the tediousness of it but more so to showcase how much so many decisions cause fights between people, not just enemies/ex-friends but with loved ones as well! Would have found it more realistic than just that the FMC spent all the money on stupid expensive throw pillows. That move alone made me disassociate with the FMC because the audacity!! (I’m in accounting so it makes sense haha). Looking forward to another book by this other though! I do really like the chemistry she builds between relationships.

Thank you NetGalley for an arc of this book in exchange for my honest review. I wanted to love this book so much with how much I love Savor It…but unfortunately this just was not it for me. While this had many of the tropes that I love (marriage of convenience, second chance romance, forced proximity, “enemies”/rivals to lovers), even those pros could not sway me over the bickering of the two main characters. Truly, the bickering felt more like the all-out screaming rage matches that siblings have growing up (I speak from experience) or that of two people who are toxic for each other and should have been in a relationship in the first place. And the pranks just felt juvenile and I felt myself physically cringe anytime one came up. I did enjoy their relationship once they figured their shit out and actually communicated with each other, but the journey to get there just didn’t feel believable.

When they were younger, LaRynn and Deacon would spend summers together because their grandmothers were best friends. One summer they finally got together. But when they get caught in a compromising position by LaRynn’s father, Deacon acts like what they had was nothing. It was the last time she ever wanted to see him. Ten years later, cruel fate has them getting married to save her grandmother’s house. The house they spent multiple summers in has been left them. There was a fire that destroyed a good bit of home, and a renovation that was done years ago was not permitted. Unfortunately, neither of them have the money it would take to fix the home. Since LaRynn dropped out of law school, her father has been restricting her funds. But if she gets married, then she has full access to her trust. This is how Deacon and LaRynn find themselves married to each other. It’s temporary though. Just until they are done fixing the house. The more they work together on fixing the house the more old feelings resurface. But if they were to give their relationship a second chance, they’ll need to confront their past and learn to let their walls down.

The Co-Op is the second book I’ve read by Tarah DeWitt and I loved it. The storyline and characters were well developed. Tarah wrote a beautiful story about two characters that had messed up families and childhoods, but were still able to find love with each other. LaRynn didn’t get the love she needed from her parents. She didn’t want to be demanding or needy, and was afraid to open up to people because eventually they wouldn’t be there anymore. Deacon’s parents made him feel like he wasn’t good enough. This caused LaRynn and Deacon to unintentionally hurt each other when they were younger. I was glad that they were able to talk things through and get their second chance at love. I really enjoyed this book, and I will definitely be reading more books by Tarah.

Thank you St. Martin’s Press and Tarah DeWitt for the ARC!

I love Tarah DeWitt’s writing, so I was very excited to read The Co-Op. It was a beautiful, emotional second chance love story. I loved LaRynn and Deacon as individuals, as well as both their platonic and romantic relationship. Sometimes I don’t enjoy flashbacks or dual timelines in books but I appreciated the flashbacks in this book. It helped me understand each character and I loved getting to read about the unique way they met each other. If you enjoy marriage of convenience, slow burn, or second chance romance with palpable tension and unresolved feelings, you should definitely read The Co-Op.

I love Tarah DeWitts writing and really enjoyed this! I am a sucker for marriage of convenience because it always leads to forced proximity, and the fact they have to live together in the house made for some excellent tension. I also enjoyed the second chance romance element and the slight enemies to lovers. I loved the flashback to their past together. As always, Tarah writes with such heart and will always be a go to author for me!

I absolutely loved this. The connection between the characters was full of tension and authenticity. I also loved the setting of the home renovation with them having to be forced proximity of them living within the project. It’s one of my favorite romances of this year.

The Co-op is a steamy story about restoration and renovation, and uncovering all the things that build character within ourselves. It’s about the never-ending construction project that partnership is, and finding enjoyment at every stage.

Tropes:
Second Chance Romance
Marriage of Convenience
Forced Proximity
"My Wife"
HEA
No third-act breakup

This might be one of the most pleasant and unique books I've read in 2025. The characters were well developed, the plot kept me engaged, and the BANTER between LaRynn and Deacon was so delicious. I also really enjoyed the flashbacks to their teenage years. It increased the depth of their relationship and WHY they acted the way they did as adults. Bonus points for no 3rd act breakup. The conflict was unique to the plot and the resolution helped round out the book nicely. Solid 4-star read for me.

I haven't had the chance to finish reading this one yet, so I suppose this is more of a pending/tbd review, but I still wanted to share my thoughts thus far as I'm not sure when I'll get back to it. I really enjoyed Savor It by Tarah Dewitt so I had high hopes in starting The Co-Op. I love the premise of the book and marriage of convenience is probably one of my top tier tropes.

However, I've found it difficult to connect with or root for the FMC in the book which has, in turn, made it a bit of a struggle to pick back up when I have other options that hook me from the very start. After seeing a few other reviews that mention the marriage of convenience trope, which sold me on requesting this book, is barely present (and, according to some, wholly unnecessary and out of place) I've decided to pause my reading in favor of finishing others on my TBR.

Ultimately, I really enjoy Tarah Dewitt's writing in general, so I'm hoping once I do get to this one again my initial impressions will change. As of right now I'm not calling it a DNF, it's just a... NAB (need a break)?

Love me a good enemies to lovers! The Co-op was a little underwhelming in the romance department but the story was good!! I love dual pov and the “before” chapters were great to really show the depth of the characters and the history!

I adored DeWitt's other book Savor It, and I did enjoy this one but not as much. I didn't feel a connection between the romance and didn't like the FMC that much, so that definitely had an impact on my review. I will still check out books from the author but so far they've been hit and miss out of 2.

Thank you NetGalley for the ebook arc. It’s not my favorite by Tarah DeWitt, but still 4 star worthy. This book was well written and cute, following two unlikely people drawn together after she inherits her grandmother’s house and he has been living in it to fix it up for his grandmother.

Such a fun new romcom from DeWiit! Tons of repressed tension from the roommate situation, the angst of the secondchance romance, and all the heart and wit of her dialogue. Loved it.

I love the writing. Tarah is so great at writing and explaining who her characters are. I enjoyed both of them so much! I really want to read more books by her!!

Thank you to the publisher and netgalley for this ARC in exchange for a honest review. Cute romance story!

This is a delightful, slow-burn romance that blends humor, heartfelt moments, and a charming enemies-to-lovers dynamic. Author crafts a story filled with witty banter and protagonists show authentic emotional growth.

Witty, warm, and full of chemistry. The Co-op is a cozy slow-burn romance with just the right mix of banter and heart. Loved this book so much!

Thank you so much to St. Martin's Press and Netgalley for the advanced copy.

LaRynn Lavigne and Deacon Leeds had a hot and heavy summer when they were kids, and years later, they find themselves with shared ownership of a building left to them by their grandmothers. As they are forced to live and work together to renovate the deteriorating building, miscommunications from the past hang in the shadows of their reconnection.

While I've enjoyed other books by Tarah, this one just didn't hit as hard. I love slow burns but this one felt a little more dragged out than necessary, and didn't burn as much as I'd like. I kept finding myself losing interest. Not gonna lie, I was definitely siding with Deacon when he discovered all of the expensive pillows she brought home when they were supposed to be on a tight budget for the reno.

But overall, it was a sweet second chance story as the two join a marriage of convenience to help fund their renovations. Both are dealing with loss of loved ones and abandonment issues, and their journey to finding comfort and support in each other is lovely.

Tarah Dewitt can truly do no wrong. I have cuteness aggression towards her and the characters she writes. I just want to squeeze them.

Tarah never fails to make me want to take the risk of falling in love in real life and that’s so special to me.

I’d let Deacon ruin my life any time. I will eat up a marriage of convenience EVERY time.

Tarah, you’re stuck with me forever because I’m obsessed with you queen.

The Co-Op by Tarah Dewitt needs to be added to your TBR right now! This is an outstanding second chance rom-com and I could not put it down! I will definitely be reading more books by this author and recommending this one to all of my friends. Thank you NetGalley, the author, & the publisher for an ARC of this title in exchange for my honest opinion.