First of all, the synopsis grabbed me. Love a book that involves a true crime podcast. This book is all about revenge. Seriously this book was so good and I cant recommend it enough. You wont be able to put it down.

I I unfortunately DNS this book at 40% in. This was just not for me. I did not enjoy the writing style or the storyline.

I’ve read a few thrillers that involve true crime podcasts. This one isn’t the best I’ve read, but it’s also not the worst. The concept of Poe’s podcast is unique and it ultimately causes her a lot of trouble. While I think Poe herself is interesting, I couldn’t help but feel that her character development was very surface level. This is a very quick read, mainly because the chapters are so short so they’re easy to get through and I definitely wanted to find out how the story would end. I did find the reveal slightly underwhelming and a little predictable, but I liked the final chapter. (3.75/5)

**This ARC was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.**

Whoosh. From the beginning, this is a gripping novel, and the pacing never lets you rest.

Poe Webb has a popular true crime podcast. What sets hers apart from the many other true crime podcasts that are out there is that she has people anonymously admit their crimes. Though it’s anonymous, she can’t guarantee that the police or FBI won’t come after them.

Poe knows about crime because she witnessed her mother get murdered when Poe was just thirteen years old. Now, a man comes on her show claiming to be her mother’s killer. Poe knows that’s impossible because her mother’s murderer is dead. Whoever this man is will stop at nothing to get her to confess to what she did.

NetGalley provided an advance copy of this novel, which RELEASES JANUARY 14, 2025.

Loved loved this book. This book had me hooked since the beginning of the story. I could not stop reading. Was a great read overall, it did not disappoint. About to start Mister Tender’s Girll

"Tell Me What You Did" is a gripping narrative that explores the intricate layers of confession, morality, and the enduring impact of past actions. At the center of this story is Poe Webb, a podcast host who invites guests to anonymously share their wrongdoings. While she immerses herself in the shadows of others' secrets, Poe carries a haunting truth of her own: she killed her mother’s murderer, believing him to be dead until a man claiming to be that very person appears on her show. This unexpected encounter forces her to confront her buried past.

The plot unfolds through Poe's podcast, where the anonymity provided to guests allows them to candidly discuss their darkest deeds. This creates an engaging dynamic, drawing listeners into the confessions while Poe struggles to maintain emotional distance from the crimes being revealed. However, when the mysterious man claims to be her mother’s killer, her life spirals into chaos, compelling her to reevaluate her own actions and the moral complexities intertwined with them.

Poe Webb is portrayed as a multifaceted protagonist and a skilled podcast host who uses her platform to unveil the secrets of others while grappling with her own guilt over her mother’s murder. The enigmatic man serves as both an antagonist and a catalyst for her journey, challenging her to reflect on her past decisions and the ethical boundaries she has crossed.

Carter Wilson’s writing style is crisp and engaging, characterized by skillful pacing and sharp prose that draw readers into the depths of his characters’ psyches. He effectively builds tension and suspense throughout the narrative, creating a story that captivates from beginning to end.

Positioned within the psychological thriller genre, "Tell Me What You Did" masterfully blends elements of mystery and suspense while delving into universal themes such as revenge, morality, and the complexities of human nature. The novel raises thought-provoking questions about confession and whether one can truly escape their past.

A significant theme revolves around justice and the nature of good versus evil. Are those who commit murder always villains? Is it possible for someone to move beyond their previous actions? These inquiries resonate with contemporary discussions surrounding crime, punishment, and societal judgment.

In summary, "Tell Me What You Did" presents a riveting and thought-provoking reading experience that entertains and encourages readers to reflect on deeper moral questions regarding guilt, redemption, and the consequences of our choices. The narrative's brisk pace and engaging style make it accessible to a broad audience, including those who may not typically consider themselves avid readers. While some might find the characters lacking in emotional depth or the plot twists somewhat predictable, the novel remains a compelling exploration of the darker facets of human nature.

tell me what you did | ARC review✨

poe is a true crime podcaster, but the best part—she talks to the criminals. she invites people onto her show and has them confess to crimes they’ve committed; however, the tables are turned when she interviews the man who murdered her mother. crazier still: how can he be on the show, when poe has already murdered him???

the synopsis of this book had me dying to read it—and it absolutely did not disappoint. i was hooked and on edge the entire time. the story was beautifully crafted, and as a consistent thriller reader, i found the plot to be very unique and refreshing! i’d give this book 10 stars if i could!

throw this one onto your tbr asap🤩

tell me what you did releases january 14, 2025!

thank you @netgalley and @poisonedpenpress for the chance to read and review this book ahead of time👻

The premise pulled me in- imagine witnessing your mother's murder then going on to host a podcast where people can anonymously share their crimes. Very interesting and unique! The execution fell a little flat for me and I didn't have any connection to any character. It was still a mostly decent read.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC of this book.

Tell Me What You Did is my first book by Carter Wilson and what a first book it was. Poe Webb watched her mother be murdered as a child and is now the host of a true crime podcast where callers anonymously confess their crimes. When a man calls in relaying information that only Poe and the killer would know about that day, her seemingly perfect and easy life begins to head off kilter. This book was written in a single POV but told between past and present with the use of podcast transcripts. This book had me guessing and second guessing all of my theories right up until the end. I could not put it down and highly recommend.

Motivated by her mother's murder years ago, Poe Webb hosts a true crime podcast where callers anonymously confess to their crimes. Poe remains unaffected by her callers' confessions until a man calls in claiming to her murdered Poe's mother. This shocking revelation is even more surprising to Poe as she believes that her mother's murderer is already dead.

“Tell Me What You Did” by Carter Wilson is a visceral thriller that doesn’t let you go until the very last word. Wilson does a fantastic job at building dread. The protagonist, if we are bold enough to call her that, Poe is the leading lady of a podcast called “Tell Me What You Did’. She allows guests to confess their darkest sins with the understanding that illegal activity may lead to arrest. Poe knows all too well what it is like to have skeletons in your closet and her next guest is going to turn the tables on her and force Poe to confront them.

"Tell Me What You Did" is a gripping narrative that explores the intricate layers of confession, morality, and the enduring impact of past actions. At the center of this story is Poe Webb, a podcast host who invites guests to anonymously share their wrongdoings. While she immerses herself in the shadows of others' secrets, Poe carries a haunting truth of her own: she killed her mother’s murderer, believing him to be dead until a man claiming to be that very person appears on her show. This unexpected encounter forces her to confront her buried past.

The plot unfolds through Poe's podcast, where the anonymity provided to guests allows them to candidly discuss their darkest deeds. This creates an engaging dynamic, drawing listeners into the confessions while Poe struggles to maintain emotional distance from the crimes being revealed. However, when the mysterious man claims to be her mother’s killer, her life spirals into chaos, compelling her to reevaluate her own actions and the moral complexities intertwined with them.

Poe Webb is portrayed as a multifaceted protagonist and a skilled podcast host who uses her platform to unveil the secrets of others while grappling with her own guilt over her mother’s murder. The enigmatic man serves as both an antagonist and a catalyst for her journey, challenging her to reflect on her past decisions and the ethical boundaries she has crossed.

Carter Wilson’s writing style is crisp and engaging, characterized by skillful pacing and sharp prose that draw readers into the depths of his characters’ psyches. He effectively builds tension and suspense throughout the narrative, creating a story that captivates from beginning to end.

Positioned within the psychological thriller genre, "Tell Me What You Did" masterfully blends elements of mystery and suspense while delving into universal themes such as revenge, morality, and the complexities of human nature. The novel raises thought-provoking questions about confession and whether one can truly escape their past.

A significant theme revolves around justice and the nature of good versus evil. Are those who commit murder always villains? Is it possible for someone to move beyond their previous actions? These inquiries resonate with contemporary discussions surrounding crime, punishment, and societal judgment.

In summary, "Tell Me What You Did" presents a riveting and thought-provoking reading experience that entertains and encourages readers to reflect on deeper moral questions regarding guilt, redemption, and the consequences of our choices. The narrative's brisk pace and engaging style make it accessible to a broad audience, including those who may not typically consider themselves avid readers. While some might find the characters lacking in emotional depth or the plot twists somewhat predictable, the novel remains a compelling exploration of the darker facets of human nature.

For me, this one was just fine. I thought the premise was extremely promising; however I had a problem with the execution. I’m really disappointed that we got the “second live stream” bits from the beginning. If we got the story as it played out, I think it would have been a bit more jaw dropping. I also think we learned too much too soon. I.e. the face that she killed Hutchins in NY. Overall this was alright, but I didn’t find it jaw dropping & I wish we didn’t get the dual timelines.

This is my first time reading a Carter Wilson book and can’t believe I’ve never heard of this author before! Tell Me What You Did was just flat out creepy with edge to it. This book is one of those books that make you scared of the long dark hallway in your house 😂! Would recommend to all of my spooky book lovers. THANK YOU for this ARC!!

Tell Me What You Did by Carter Wilson is an intriguing read, but it didn’t quite hit the mark for me. The premise is interesting, and the story does have its moments, but I found the pacing a bit slow at times, especially with the interview sections. They seemed to interrupt the flow and made it harder to stay fully engaged.

That being said, I wouldn’t call it a bad book—it definitely has potential. I think the experience might be different on audiobook, where the story could flow more naturally with the right narration. I’m willing to give it another chance in that format, as I feel like the pacing might improve and I could enjoy the story more. Worth a read if you enjoy slower-paced thrillers, but personally, I think the audiobook might suit me better!

This book was predictable for me. I solely read most thrillers so I am very good with predictability. The characters were just okay. Nothing spectacular. The plot wasn't very different. I think I'm growing tired of all the books that take place with a pod caster it is overdone at this point.

Thank you to netgalley and to the publishers for this arc copy. I thought this was a really good book I was nervous at first I’m not a huge fan of the whole podcast trope anymore but I’m happy I gave this one a chance . I loved the short and simple chapters it makes it super easy to stop and pick up and not be confused because you stopped half way through a chapter. I podcast trop that he did I thing was different then anything I’ve read I feel so that was another plus . I was entertained for most of the book I just do feel it dragged on at some points when I don’t think it needed to that’s why I gave it 4 stars. I will be getting more of this authors books to put on the TBR

This was such a fun and unexpected thriller. I really loved reading this one and I highly recommend checking it out!

This has to be one of the most fascinating thrillers I've read in a while. This is perfect for the fans of None of This Is True by Lisa Jewell, if you really liked the podcast aspect of it. This book defines morally grey characters. The mystery is supercharged and damn interesting. You'll keep reading way past your bedtime to know what happens. It deserves all the stars just for being so entertaining!

4 stars out of 5.

I really enjoyed reading this book and was pulled in from the start. I like how the book kept shifting from present day to the podcast. I did find the big reveal to be predictable but I still enjoyed reading the book. The short chapters kept me wanting to reading on and I would recommend this to anyone looking for a fast paced thriller.

In Tell Me What You Did, we meet Poe, who runs a true crime podcast where people can confess their crimes anonymously. One day, a man on the podcast tells Poe he was the one who killer her mother all those years ago. She didn't believe him because she already killed that man a few years ago. So who is this person on her show that has intimate details of her mothers killing? Some of the details he knows, could only come from the killer. Poe learns she is in real danger as the man gets closer to her, even threatening her family and friends.

Thank you Netgalley and Poisoned Pen Press for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.