Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I'm a huge fan of anything Scotland since my ancestors are from there. Some Like It Scot is a fun witty read. Katie Campbell has a wonderful sense of humor. Even though trouble seems to follow here everywhere and she's clumsy, her puns keep everyone laughing. Graeme is the typical Scotsman, rugged (ripped), tall and hot. The banter and most of the characters are enjoyable and likeable. Even Kristy the terror on a bike. I truly enjoyed Some Like It Scot. Pepper Basham writes so that the reader can easily visualize the characters and the location without too much detail.

Was this review helpful?

rom the very first chapter, I was hooked. The banter had me laughing, the tender moments had me swooning, and the emotional ones had me tearing up. It was everything I look for in a romance: heartfelt, fun, and deeply satisfying.

Was this review helpful?

THIS WAS PERFECT!!!! a clean romance with so much depth it weird in this day and age. god i only have positive things to say about this book, go buy and read it !!!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and the publisher for not only the electronic advanced copy but also the audiobook advanced copy!

I love Scotland and I was so excited to get a copy of this book. And it did not disappoint. Not only was the story incredible but the narrators were perfect for the characters!

Was this review helpful?

It's rare to find a tall, curvy girl as the main character in a rom com. This one had it and did it so well. I loved this fun story set in Scotland where we follow travel writer Katie on her MISSadventures. I loved the main male character as well with all his gruff. These two both are dealing with the grief of losing a sibling and have quite a few comedic moments that felt almost a bit slapstick. I laughed, I teared up. I appreciated the heart that was here in this story. I also really appreciate when a romcom has such good banter that you can feel the chemistry without taking things to the bedroom. Fun times all around in this sweet romcom.

Was this review helpful?

Initially, Some Like It Scot by Pepper Basham offers the idyllic Scottish escape.

Travel writer Katie Campbell jumps at the chance to review an immersive Edwardian experience in Scotland, reconnecting with her family's Scottish roots. When her clumsy nature attracts the strong embrace of the castle owner and grumpy Scotsman, Graeme MacKerrow, the two tumble into an unlikely attraction for each other. As they bond over their shared grief and love for the tight-knit community, Katie must decide if it is time to trade in her wanderlust for a place to call home.

One of the first offerings to catch the reader's eye is Katie's uniqueness as a narrator. She has a strong, intelligent voice and an evident expertise in her field. It's effortless to slip into her point of view, experiencing Scotland through her adventurous and curious point of view.

Basham excels in bringing a fictional Scotland to life, providing intricate detail to the lush landscapes and cobblestone streets of this tucked-away gem of a town.

The first half of the book is particularly strong as she introduces us to the authentic world outside of the Edwardian experience at the castle. From friendly shop owners to opinionated locals, every corner of this rural highland setting is populated with colourful run-ins. Even when the zany Edwardian experience, with its inauthentic details and obscurely lavish meals, threatens to take over, it offers a comical over-the-top plot.

Unfortunately, the enchanting setting isn't elevated by the chemistry of our leading couple.

While Graeme owning the castle is a fun little twist to spring on Katie, it isn't enough whimsy to give their chemistry that much-needed spark. It's a typical rom-com where a grumpy Scotsman and an American tourist fall in love despite their contrasting sunny and rainy dynamic. There's no identity specific to these characters beyond a shared tragedy and uncommon body images -- of which this book uses too frequently to establish that uniqueness. The plot is painfully predictable, and much of the romantic dialogue lands flat because these characters are so detached from one another.

A clean romance still has to find ways to establish intimacy, if not physically, then through human connection. These characters try their best, but it all feels rather superficial without a more profound sense of why they make for a perfect pairing beyond the convenience of being in each other's proximity.

Some Like It Scot is a light and harmless romance. Go in expecting a cookie-cutter Scottish love story with familiar tropes and predictable execution, and you might just enjoy this one.

Sadly, no character captures this reader's heart enough to stay in the warm embrace of this story for longer than needed.

Was this review helpful?

Some Like It Scot is a charming, lighthearted rom-com that delivers the cozy appeal of a grumpy/sunshine romance set against a picturesque Scottish backdrop. Pepper Basham creates likable characters and engaging banter, making the story easy to read and enjoy. The clean, feel-good tone is perfect for readers who enjoy sweet, wholesome romance.

That said, the plot is fairly predictable, and some character arcs could have been developed more fully to deepen emotional engagement. While entertaining, the story relies on familiar tropes and doesn’t offer many surprises or standout moments.

Overall, Some Like It Scot is a pleasant, cozy read—perfect for fans of lighthearted, clean romance, though it doesn’t leave a lasting impression.

Was this review helpful?

I received this book from Netgalley and Thomas Nelson Fiction in exchange for my honest review. Katie Campbell is a travel writer and is known for her mishaps that happen during her adventures, her MissAdventures. She is traveling to Scotland and taking part in an Edwardian-themed event in a lovely Scottish manor. Graeme MacKerrow is the town grump who is trying to preserve his family estate. While Katie is exploring this lovely town, she gets to know the MacKerrow family and starts to wonder where "home" is since she is always traveling. I loved the dual perspective between Katie and Graeme, seeing Katie's restlessness and Graeme's guarded heart. I enjoyed the description that Pepper was able to write about the characters, the Isles of Mull, and the Edwardian experience. This is a kiss-only romance, with a second chance, and full of characters finding themselves. #SomeLikeItScot #Netgalley

Was this review helpful?

SOME LIKE IT SCOT
-Pepper Basham



Katie Campbell
Graeme McKerrow


Thank you @netgalley and Thomas Nelson Books for this beautiful book.

Set in the picturesque setting of Scottish countryside this is a slow burn, sweet and a clean romance book.

Katie Campbell a travel blog writer popularly known as 'Miss Adventure' for her clumsy personality, is sent on a three week Ewardian experience to Craighill house where she meets the grumpy, broody and mysterious Graeme.

Between the dancing lessons, costume trials and local folklore she manages to get herself in all kinds of trouble which not only makes her followers entertain, she also becomes the talk of the town and manages to fall in love with the said grumpy Graeme who also owns the manor she is staying in.

The charms of Scotland and the beautiful writing easily draws you in from the very first page. The slow burn, grumpy x sunshine trope and the witty banter between the MMC makes it so good. But what I liked more was the beauty of the small town, the people that live here, the love they share.

I would recommend this book to those who want a break from the fast paced, city life, insta love books. Stories like this with small town charm, search of home and falling in love not just with that one person who was destined for you but his whole family is something I adore and enjoy reading.

So pick this one and get lost in the world of Katie and Graeme.



Toodles💕

Was this review helpful?

Some Like It Scot by Pepper Basham is the loveliest novel. I really loved the main character in this novel and all her quirks. The Scottish setting made me long for a trip there! I’ve long enjoyed books by this author and I think this is one of her best. I love her characters and how they feel real. I think this book would be best enjoyed as an audiobook to best experience the Scottish pronunciation of words. Great book overall! I received a digital copy of this book from the publisher with no obligations. These opinions are entirely my own.

Was this review helpful?

From the moment I opened Some Like It Scot, I knew I was in for a story that blended charm, humor, and just the right touch of romance. Pepper Basham brings together the beauty of Scotland with the warmth of a love story that feels both swoony and grounded.

The novel follows Weezie and James, whose paths cross under circumstances that are equal parts awkward and endearing. Their banter is sparkling, full of wit and tension, and it’s impossible not to root for them even as they navigate misunderstandings, cultural clashes, and the ghosts of their pasts. What I loved most was how their relationship never felt rushed—it’s layered with friendship, trust, and gradual vulnerability.

Basham’s descriptions of Scotland are a treat. The rugged landscapes, the cadence of the dialogue, even the little cultural quirks—it all feels alive, adding atmosphere without ever overshadowing the heart of the story.

The pacing moves briskly, with plenty of laugh-out-loud moments balanced by quieter, heartfelt scenes. Yes, it leans into some of the classic rom-com tropes, but it does so with warmth and sincerity, which makes it feel comforting rather than predictable.


This is a delightful blend of humor, romance, and Scottish charm. Weezie and James are a couple you can’t help but fall for, and Basham’s storytelling makes the journey feel both lighthearted and deeply heartfelt. If you enjoy rom-coms with a dash of Highland spirit, Some Like It Scot is a cozy, heart-lifting read.

Was this review helpful?

Falling in love with Scotland just got easier.
“It seems to me we need to pray you find home, Katie-girl, because every wandering heart needs a place to rest.

Some Like It Scot is a sweet contemporary romance set against the picturesque backdrop of the Scottish countryside. Katie Campbell, a travel writer, is sent to a historic manor for a three-week Edwardian-themed experience. Think Downton Abbey meets small-town charm. Between dancing lessons, period costumes, and local folklore, Katie is quickly enchanted—especially by the manor’s loyal and swoon-worthy local, Graeme McKerrow.

The Scottish cast of characters is delightfully quirky and endearing, bringing warmth and personality to the story. Graeme stands out with his humble nature and dedication to his family and heritage. His meet-cute with Katie (involving a broken staircase and a literal fall) kicks off their slow-burn romance.

What I enjoyed most was the cozy atmosphere, the rich cultural elements, and just how perfect Graeme is as the hero of a Scottish romance. The dual POV adds depth, letting us see both Katie and Graeme’s inner thoughts and emotional journeys.

However, the romance itself felt a bit lacking. The main couple didn’t share enough page time to fully develop their chemistry. Much of the story is spent in introspection rather than interaction, which made it harder for me to feel invested in their relationship.

Katie’s misadventures, a key part of her character as a klutzy travel writer dubbed “Miss Adventure,” occasionally felt forced and overly cartoonish. While meant to add humor, some scenarios didn’t quite land for me.

Overall, Some Like It Scot is a sweet and cozy read with plenty of charm, though the romance could have used more depth and interaction.

Was this review helpful?

I have thoroughly enjoyed Pepper Basham’s writing. This book is thoughtful and creative, lighthearted and humorous! Katie and Graeme are the perfect pair, even if it does take them awhile to realize it. And, who doesn’t love a book set in Scotland?

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

I read this book on the plane on my last trip to...Scotland! It was perfect. So funny and delightful, with all the references to Scotland that I enjoyed my trip all that much more. Lots of laughs but cutesy moments too. Loved the book club and the scheming of the the women in the village who openly welcomed this woman, this Campbell (of all the clans), to their fold. A bit predictable but delightfully so with a fairytale ending. A perfect companion for my trip but you can journey to Scotland in your mind as you read this fun rom-com, with all the good feel vibes. Many thanks to #somelikeitscot #pepperbasham #thomasnelson for the chance to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

This book was SUCH a fun read! Some Like It Scot had me grinning from the first chapter. The banter between the characters is hilarious, the slow burn romance was perfect and the Scottish setting just makes everything extra charming.

The perfect combination of laugh out loud moments and deeply moving ones.

If you like rom-coms with sass, heart, and a bit of Scottish flair, this is definitely one to add to your list 🥰

Was this review helpful?

Can someone send me to the highlands so I can relive this story as the main character? This is a lighthearted story with some good nuggets. A very easy and engaging read.

Was this review helpful?

This book was lovely. It was warm and deep and humorous. I cannot recommend it enough. I'm having trouble summing up the words to make a potential reader understand how much they will love this book. Just read it.

Was this review helpful?

So good, I read it twice. That's right another book I read via kindle and then via audio within the span of 4 months!

I was already planning on rereading this on audio, but when I needed something in my ears to drown out and distract me from some dental work I needed done, I knew revisiting this story would literally be the perfect prescription. And I was right. This was the perfect story to whisk me out of the dental chair and away to Scotland.

Basham excels at writing quirky and loveable characters full of flaws, but also full of a plethora of admirable qualities who you cannot help but adore. And Katie fits in that group beautifully. She is smart, kind, funny, clumsy with a penchant for disaster, and not at all your stereotypical rom com heroine. She has a complicated family situation and travel is her literal job.

But on the flip side you have Graham, this giant of a man who is a bit gruff, but loyal and devoted to his family and his heritage. Also complex and dreamy!

My very favorite theme in romances is when the leads can see each other for who they are at their core. And when at one point Graham really reveals to Katie that he sees her, I wanted to stand and cheer. It was so sweet.

Plus, there are so many more humorous and poignant moments throughout that deserve all the love.

So what I'm saying is, if you love a good clean rom com, don't pass this one up.

Thanks to Thomas Nelson for the complimentary digital and audio copies. I received a complimentary copy of this book but was not required to leave a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Unexpected delight. Really enjoyed this story and couldn’t put it down. Read all night. Strongly recommend and will read the author again. Great characters and wonderful writing.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a huge fan of Pepper Basham. She writes well-developed characters and always has fun, engaging plots. That said, this one isn't one of my favorites, in large part because I struggle to get into 1st person novels. They don't connect with me the way deep 3rd pov does. I'm finding romcoms aren't my cup of tea, either-- I love Basham's humor in her other novels, such as her Mitchell's series.

Was this review helpful?