Member Reviews

This graphic novel is gorgeous. The watercolour illustrations, particularly during the travel scenes across the oceans, were stunning. It complimented the story so well.

I had never ready anything from Ursula K. Le Guin, and I thought the graphic novel would be an easy first step for me. I fell in love with the voice and the characters almost instantly. It's been so long since I read a classic fantasy like this, and I'm ready for more.

It's easy enough to read that I would recommend it when you're in a reading slump, but also complicated enough that you'll be sure to remember it.

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful interpretation of Ursula Le Guins novel. The story follows Ged as he seeks to become a powerful wizard. But, he ends up facing the consequences of delving too deep. It is a wonderful retelling that keeps to the original story and presents it i. A great mediums for teens to read. The watercolors style art is whimsical and a little melancholy. This perfectly reflects the tone of the book and adds to magic of the graphic novel. Hopefully this will lead to more readers enjoying the full series of Earthsea novels.

Was this review helpful?

A transformative and enriching experience. I can think of no better way to journey back to Earthsea after years away than our story of young Ged paired with truly jaw-dropping art. Easily, one of the most beautiful graphic novels I have read, there are few things more rewarding as a graphic novel reader than revisiting a beloved story in a new medium; and seeing how this new medium delivers or falls short. This is certainly a novel that delivers. While one would never doubt Le Guin and say her novel falls short, there is a special something to see the scale and passion brought to the artwork that brings this telling to a whole new level.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Harper Collins for an advanced reader copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. The graphic novel adaptation of A Wizard of Earthsea is stunning and one of the best adaptations of an original book I have seen in a while. The graphic art is clean and really helps to draw the reader in to a book that has been around for a while! The only reason I didn’t rate this book higher is because at times while reading, it felt like it was geared towards a younger age like middle grade instead of young adult into adult. Nevertheless, it was amazing and renewed my love for this book!

Was this review helpful?

Of course a fantastic story, but the graphic novel adaptation was very thoughtful and the artwork was superb.

Was this review helpful?

This graphic novel rendition of the classic is absolutely gorgeous. So much is said through the moody and expressive paintings on the page. The images set the mood, reveal the characters, and move the story along. The landscapes and changing colors were my favorite part. The art really captures the quiet, seeking journey of Ged.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and HarperCollins for the digital advanced reader copy of this novel.

This edition takes the words written y Ursula K. Le Guin and blends them gorgeously with illustrations from Fred Fordham.

Ged was the greatest sorcerer in Earthsea, but in his youth he was reckless. He was known as Sparrowhawk in those days, and in his hunger for power and knowledge he did the unthinkable. He released a shadow, terrible and ruthless, into the world when he tampered with long-buried secrets. This is the tale of his testing, his taming of an ancient dragon, and his crossing of death’s threshold to restore the balance of the world.

I will start by saying that I have not read the original Earthsea novel. I chose to request this ARC because I love fantasy and thought the synopsis combined with the artwork fit my preferred reading material. I was impressed with how well the dialogue was used throughout the novel. There were panels that needed no words and they were given the space to breathe. The dialogue used was well written and improved the overall atmosphere of the story rather than the words becoming distracting. It was very well done.

The images in this graphic novel are simply beautiful. I loved that the characters were mostly people of color and that the whole vibe of being in a world of islands was very obvious. It felt as if I were being submerged in the atmosphere. Everything is done in muted earth tones that lend a heavy but somehow comforting feel to the story.

I would recommend this graphic novel adaptation to anyone who loves magic, mystery, and immersion into the world that Le Guin built with her fantasy novels.

Was this review helpful?

firstly, thank you to the publisher for an arc.

this is perhaps the most beautiful adaptation of a novel i’ve seen, especially for such an important and beloved one such as wizard of earthsea.

it’s as if illustrator fred fordham painted each scene (i’m not familiar with his works so i don’t know if that’s his method) and the emotion is clear in each frame. i loved the depiction of each character. especially ged's animal companion hoeg. the whole package is absolutely phenomenal.

absolutely worth a read for fans of sci-fi/fantasy and fans of le guin

Was this review helpful?

I’ve never read Earthsea, so this is all I have to base things on. I think the art was great for the story, capturing a loneliness and the expanse of the world quite well. I do wonder feel a bit may be missing, especially in the magical aspects. Still, this was a great story and the graphic novel successfully conveys a lot just with images.

Note: ARC provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is a beautiful graphic version of Ursula K. Le Guin's classic, A Wizard of Earthsea. The world building is top notch, and the artist really captures the feel of loneliness, frustration, trying to prove oneself, and adventure.

Was this review helpful?

As a kid I loved this book, so picking up an ARC for the graphic novel brought back a lot of fond memories. To start with the good (and it’s very good) the artwork is lovely. The water colors add a softness and a more natural feeling, and the landscapes — especially the ocean — was perfect. The vastness of it, the smallness of Ged’s boat, the size of the sky, it was all beautiful to look at.

However, I’m not sure this really captures as much of the book’s spirit as I would have liked. Due to the nature of the adaptation a lot was lost because it’s all visual rather than introspective. The artist managed to get a lot of the story done in a way that felt respectful to the story and the characters, but I’m not sure if this would bring in someone who wasn’t already a fan.

However, if you are already a fan, then this is a wonderful companion piece. Thank you so very much to Net Galley and the publisher for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, HarperCollins Children's Books, Clarion Books, Ursula K. Le Guin, and Fred Fordham for the opportunity to read the graphic novel adaptation of A Wizard of Earthsea: A Graphic Novel in exchange for an honest review.

Based on the first novel from the Tales of Earthsea series, published in 1968, this graphic novel adaptation introduces Le Guin's groundbreaking fantasy novel in a fresh visual light for today's contemporary audience.

The story follows Sparrowhawk, a young boy who learns of his own power and wants to gain more, though his power-seeking leads to a quest to fight his own evils. The story is rather philosophical in its magic system and lessons learned. The art is almost like a water color style that is very distinct and atmospheric of the archipelago in Earthsea.

This is a great graphic novel adaptation for middle grade (though it might be just slightly advanced) and teen readers, as well as adults who grew up with Earthsea and want to enjoy a new approach to a classic or share with their families.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

This was a fun graphic novel. This was a great reading experience and I really enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

Stunningly beautiful artwork of a classic. The brush strokes gave a water color feel to the story that made it feel like a classic. I loved it.

Was this review helpful?

stunning work. absolutely does le guin’s masterwork justice. the earthsea cycle, as a whole, is such a sharp but delicate work, both like a warm wind and crystal-clear ice. i adore it, and i feel it inside my chest at every page. the illustrations here are each their own masterpieces. i dearly hope this series is continued in this format.

Was this review helpful?

Ursula K. Le Guin consistently tops the list of grand fantasy authors. Sadly, I know more that mentions her and yet still haven't read her work. Earthsea is her first great, and I always wondered what it would look like if her publishers hadn't pushed her to target it toward teens. Earthsea is a coming-of-age wizard's tale as Ged grows into the knowledge and experience between power and death. This version is lovingly crafted by the artist Fred Fordham. Ursula would have been proud. I credit Netgalley for gifting me with an advance copy to review.

Was this review helpful?

My thanks to NetGalley and HarperColllins Children's Books for a graphic novel adaptation of a a classic fantasy story about a boy finding his gifts, making mistakes and doing his best to try and fix them, no matter what the cost.

Growing up my town was really a mecca for books. Our library was well stocked, and even better had bag sales almost every other month, where one could fill a bag of books for a buck. From this amassed a huge amount of books, most of which I still have, plus learned how to pack things without ripping the container they were in. I remember seeing the box before I registered the title. A box from Bantam books, a plus at the time, with a dragon sleeping on a town. With Wizard in the title, I was sold, Upon reading the collection, I found a lot more going on then the usual find a dragon kill a dragon story. Sure there were dragons, but there was a lot of moments of making mistakes, of hiding, or doing things wrong. Of dealing with questions that well Dungeons and Dragons hadn't really trained my brain for. I wasn't sure what to think, and six months later needing something to read, started the books again. And enjoyed them immensely, for all the reasons I had been confused about before. Ursula K. Le Guin soon became an author I looked for, though some of the books took years for me to appreciate. This is a graphic novel retelling of the classic tale, one which readers can tell meant much to the illustrator, as much as it means to this reader. A Wizard of Earthsea: A Graphic Novel was written by Ursula K. Le Guin and illustrated and adapted by Fred Fordham and tells of a young man finding magic in the world, making a mess, and doing his best to make things right.

A young is born in a small village, soon to be without a mother. The boy's father is a village smithy, as hard as the steel he makes, and the boy grows up without much love, or a sense of family. One day the boy sees an aunt talking to animals, and the animals responding. The boy tries this trick and finds the animals come running to him, as in a stampede. This is his first taste of magic, and first mistake in magic. The boy's aunt teaches him her ways, but it is wild and without discipline, something that is helpful when the boy hides the village from marauders, but nearly dying from the magic. Saved by a local wizard, the boy is given a choice, learn the ways of magic from the wizard or travel to a school, to become powerful. The boy chooses the school, and in an act of bravado, sets loose a great evil, one that scars him, and sets him roaming. The boy learns that only by facing his troubles, can he be free of his mistake, no mater what the cost.

The graphic novel is very faithful to the book, which was overseen by Le Guin's daughter. The story holds up well, and still has the power to amaze and touch the reader. This is the first of two trilogies, and I can' recommend the books enough. The adaptation is beautiful Fordham really understands the assignment, capturing the characters, their skin colors, their actions and emotions. There are scenes of environmental beauty, long vistas of land and ocean. Villages that seem lived in, cities that catch the eye, and boats the seem to float on the page. Fordham can do quiet moments as well as action. One of the best comic adaptations I have read in a long time, and I have read quite a bit starting with the old Classics Illustrated.

A wonderful story, made even more beautiful. I am enjoying the recent adaptations made of classic works, as these serve as great introductions to works that might be hard to interest young minds in today. I know it works for me with my nephews. If one likes Le Guin, one will enjoy this, and serves as a good jumping on place for new readers. Also this serves as a good place to learn more about Fred Fordham, a person who I can't wait to see and read more of.

Was this review helpful?

A Wizard of Earthsea: A Graphic Novel, by Ursula K. Le Guin and illustrated by Fred Fordham, is an illustrated story about a boy named Sparrowhawk, and his growing-up years learning to be a wizard. It chronicles his struggles, the stages he goes through, the friends he makes, and the prideful decisions that bring about great grief in his life. This book concludes with him meeting the biggest threat of his life. My exposure to Earthsea up to this point is watching the animated movie that deals with his adult years. This story was new to me and was brought alive by the illustrations. And on that note, I should say that the watercolor pages are extraordinary, pulling me into the story like words cannot do. I could easily follow the storyline and enjoy what was almost a movie right before my eyes. The professional skill level is what I would expect with any other successful graphic novel.

I enjoy fantasy stories, and while many are without illustrations and require me to use my imagination which sometimes falls short, this book fills in the gaps with the needed pictures, intentionally pacing the story so I can absorb and enjoy what I am reading. It doesn’t take the place of the written story, of course, but now that I’ve seen this version, I can now read the version (first 4 books) I received as a gift a while back. I cannot say enough good things about this book. I highly recommend A Wizard of Earthsea for readers of all ages, who enjoy graphic novels with a fantasy twist.

Was this review helpful?

I didn't like this as much as I was hoping I would.

I think the art work is slightly disturbing, far too realistic resulting in some truly insane looking reactions.

The narration was way too dense. I know it's based on the book but I would've preferred if it was more condensed.

Not my cup of tea from someone who hasn't read the original, but I could imagine longtime fans of Earthsea would love it.

Was this review helpful?

Loved it. Images are amazing and the color just makes them pop. Perfect balance between words and pictures. Literally feels like watching a movie while reading it.

Was this review helpful?