I loved The Lady and the Highwayman and have been looking forward to reading the next book by the same author. It didn't disappoint! Tons of heart, humor, and an interesting perspective on the 1800s from characters you don't always see in romances.

Now this is a charming and romantic story! A thief and a gentleman, what more could a girl ask for? Our two protagonists are Ana and Hollis, and the story is told from their alternating views along with the penny dreadfuls that Hollis writes. You are essentially getting three stories in one! Ana is a music teacher who doubles as a thief, reclaiming items that were stolen from her family when they fell from fortune. Hollis is a spy for the Penny Dreadful society trying to find who the thief who has been stealing items is. I found this to be a charming and easy read. Romantic and sweet while also adding elements of gothic stories and adventures. If I’m being honest, I prefer this one to the first book. I really liked the development in the relationship between the two protagonists and the reasoning behind their motivations. The story was fun and I would recommend this for anyone who enjoys a good romantic novel.
*thank you netgalley for sending me an early arc in exchange for an honest review *

As someone who loved The Lady and the Highwayman, I went into this latest Sarah M. Eden book with sky-high expectations, and boy, did this book deliver! Full of chemistry, twists and turns, and scenes and arcs you'd never find in other historical romances right now, this book is bold, passionate, and hits all the right notes. Five stars! Highly recommended!

This is a fun and entertaining adventure to jump into. The characters are well written and the previously established setting for the Penny Dreadful Society proves a great backdrop. I liked the characters of Hollis and Ana and found them to be really cute together on their adventure.

The only thing I would say I wasn’t crazy about is balancing a total of 3 stories within the book. I found that I often just wanted to get back to the main story so having two others was sometimes frustrating. One story within a story seems to be a batter balance for this kind of book.

A very enjoyable read overall and I’ll be on the lookout for future works by this author!

#netgalley #thegentlemanandthethief
Love, love, loved this book! Saran M. Eden has done it again!! I love that I get 3 intriguing stories in 1 with this series. It leaves me wanting to read the book so fast so that I know how each story ends and wanting to read slowly so that they never end! So good!!!

I loved the first book in this series and had seriously high hopes for this one. Sarah does a well crafted story and always writes a good series. In the first book you have the start of the Penny Dreadful society introduced. Hollis is a member and writes stories, but is a member of the Ton of London. Ana used to be a member of the Ton until her family was cheated out of everything. These two meet in the first story and this is their adventure. It was a fun read, like the first book this includes Hollis writing a story that you get every couple of chapters. It also includes a story by King. So you really have 3 stories going on. In the first book their was only the 2 and the 2 stories were well woven together. Sadly I didn't like that there were 3 stories, it was too much. The stories had to do with each other but only slightly went along with the original story line. It was all just a little too much. Overall I enjoyed it so much and really am looking forward to this whole series.
This is a mystery with no religion. It is a proper romance with a couple sweet kisses.

So charming I almost didn't know what to do with myself. I love indulging in period dramas and lovers who spar and solve crimes. Almost like the regency's response to Nick and Nora. A ton of fun. Thank you for the ARC!

A lovely return to the Dread Penny Society. A sweet romance centered around a fun group of do-gooders. I’m a big fan of the author’s work and this one didn’t disappoint!

This latest installment of Sarah Eden’s penny dreadful stories was entertaining and enjoyable. This is the second book in the series and I would recommend you read the first. While the main characters in this story are different than those in the first there characters and plots that weave through both.
This story has a bit of mystery, two enjoyable short stories interspersed throughout, and a brief introduction to card playing in the Victorian era. I found myself watching YouTube videos to learn more about the games played in the book. Sarah does a great job researching her stories and this was no different. Her list of sources in the Author’s Note is impressive.
If you are looking for an entertaining story with romance and a touch of intrigue this would be a good book for you.

A great follow-up to The Lady & the Highwayman! I love that the heroes in these books aren't reformed rakes or scoundrels - it's nice to be reminded that there are just nice guys out there. The relationship between Ana and Hollis is sweet and both characters are given personalities beyond just the run-of-the-mill romance characters. Having them work through their problems rather than fight and "break up" just to have a big reunion at the end was also refreshing. I enjoyed watching Hollis prove himself to the rest of the DPS, especially since he kept his sense of humor through all of it. The best parts of the story come when Ana and Hollis team up after her secret is known to him. They prove to be perfectly matched.

It takes a talented author to make it seem effortless to write a full romance/mystery story and two penny dreadful stories and make them all page-turners. I often found myself as excited to read the next installment of one of the penny dreadfuls as I was to see what was going to happen next in the main story.

I will be waiting excitedly for the third installment in this fun and clever series!

Thank you so much for the advance reader copy of this novel. This was a delightful Victorian romance. I had read the first book but this could easily be a stand alone. I can't wait for the next book. Ana and Hollis were dliggtf as a couple and their interaction in the novel was tender. I loved he character of Very Merry and hope to see her again.. I also hope to find out who the deed master is and if Serena is found. Eden is such a talented author and appreciate this advanced reader copy. Fully recommend this book!!!!

Not long before picking up this book I read the first book in this series and was a little nervous that this second book would not live up to the first. I couldn't have been more wrong! I really enjoyed getting a closer look at Hollis and Ana's story. This book definitely was as good if not better than the first! Would highly recommend this series to anyone looking for a lighter fun read that also has some substance.

*I received an ARC copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley in return for review. All opinions are my own.*

Between 3 1/2 and 4.

This is the second book in the Penny Dreadful Society. We already know Hollis and Ana as they were secondary characters in the first story, and now it's their turn.

Hollis is a gentleman of low means and writes penny dreadful stories under a nom-de-plume. He likes Ana, likes to spend time with her, and he's the one to recommend her as a music teacher to his brother's daughter.
Ana's family used to be in society but that all changed when her father's company was bankrupt, and she's been teaching at Elizabeth's school.

They both keep secrets from each other, but when the situation arises, they help each other too, and their relationship deepens.

As for the penny dreadful stories by Mr. King and Mr. Jones—I understand their purpose, and I liked them, but not sure the jumping around the three stories was effective. It created a lot of interruptions. It would work a lot better to have the main story and then the other two stories at the end.

I received a copy from the publisher via NetGalley and this is my honest opinion.

Another win for Sarah Eden! I was desperately hoping that this second book would feature Hollis Darby--and I got my wish! Hollis Darby has sworn off his not-insignificant gambling skills after seeing the damage the vice did to his family. Instead, he makes a living secretly writing Penny Dreadful stories and spends his time rescuing people as a member of the Dread Penny Society. Ana has sworn to right the wrongs done to her family after her father lost his fortune and London Society shunned them. She has a very specific set of skills to assist her in this. When trouble finds them, it will take both their skill sets to save the day.

I absolutely love Hollis and Ana. Hollis is genial and kind and ready to be the hero when needed. Ana is smart and sweet and effective in reaching her goals. Both characters are well-developed and likeable. The plot is well-paced and intriguing, with some danger and mystery involved. The Penny Dreadful stories peppered in throughout the chapters are again entertaining and unique, much as they were in the first book of this series. And as always, I'm on pins and needles about who the Dread Master could be (please, oh please, let it be someone related to the Jonquils, lol!).

I can't wait for the next installment!

Rated PG for mild violence
--no cursing
--some mild violence
--clean romance

I was provided this ebook free from NetGalley in return for an honest opinion

This is a sweet Victorian romance with some daring adventures worthy of the penny dreadfuls. Ana Newport, a music teacher by day and thief by night, and Hollis Darby, a secret penny dreadful author, work together to discover a gambling ring that is threatening Hollis's brother.

It's a very good sequel to The Lady and the Highwayman. And like the first book, the penny dreadfuls by Mr. King and Hollis Darby's nom de plume, Lafayette Plume are interspersed throughout the book.

I received a copy of this book from netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

This was such a fun story. We follow Hollis, a peer of the realm that writes penny dreadfuls in secret, and Ana, a fallen peer of the realm that now teaches music by day and steals as the Phantom Fox by night. As they get to know one another they also uncover a sinister plot marking those of the ton and taking advantage of helpless youth. The Dreadpenny Society has been on the hunt for the Mastiff, an unknown person that controls many of the street youth and is a criminal mastermind that is greatly feared. With the help of Ana and Hollis they are able to get further in their quest to ferret out who this mastermind is and they are able to thwart one of his schemes.
Hollis and Ana work well together and with those of the society. Their strengths quickly make them invaluable to the team and it sets them up to be of more use in further down the line. I’m looking forward to more from the dread penny society and I do so hope they unmask the Mastiff before he hurts more people or ruins for lives. This was a fun clean story with lots of action and intrigue with just the right amount of romance to make it sweet.

Sarah Eden is hands down one of my favorite authors. She has an amazing talent to balance tension and humor. Every time I thought my racing heart just could't take the suspense anymore I'd turn the page and smile at Mr. Higglebottom's school for the Undead, or a witty remark from a character. Her pacing flows the story from one page to the next so you just can't put it down!  

Her writing consistently impresses me. A master of character development. I'm repeatedly invested in her characters; Hollis and Ana were no exception. There was a moment near the end of the book where I thought I knew what was coming next, and I desperately didn't want it to. I didn't want Ana to become the stereotypical damsel in distress. I should've known better. The anticipated plot point never came to be and I smiled even bigger at the strength of her characters and her ability to weave a tale. Even her stories in a story were well crafted and had me quickly turning the page. This is quickly becoming one of my new favorite series'.

Sarah Eden has been my favorite author for quite awhile now and I always look forward to stepping into one of her worlds. This Victorian novel is the second in the series but can be read as a stand alone.
One of the fantastic things about this series is the penny dreadful tales that take place throughout the story. They are so much fun and you get three stories in one.

Hollis was my favorite side character in The Lady and the Highwayman so I was delighted to find out he’d be the main character of this one.
I loved getting to really know and understand his character.
I love that Ana was the “Phantom Fox” a role you would not expect from her and nor do they.
The banter and chemistry between Ana and Hollis is delightful. I love their pairing and that we got to see plenty of Fletcher and Elizabeth as well.
Sarah does a great job of bringing attention to the hardships of this time period. The villains she has written are just the right amount of despicable and I love when the DPS, with Anas help, interrupt and break apart their dastardly plans.
Filled with plenty of action, mystery, and romance this story takes you on quite a thrilling ride. Thanks to Shadow Mountain for sending me a copy. All opinions expressed are my own.

The characters were charming in this romantic novel. I loved this author's ability to help her readers understand the trials that society was facing during that era. Her characters allowed you the ability to sympathize and cheer them to success. The story line was complex enough to keep all readers engaged. The inserting of the penny dreadful stories didn't feel as smooth of a transition as the first book could claim but it was still enjoyable.

I will admit that I love Sarah Eden's books! I have never been disappointed. I was excited to read this one, but felt a little lost with the characters. It was then I realized this was book two of a series. I quickly borrowed the first book from a library, and then all the pieces fell together. This is a different genre for her, and I loved it! I lived the intrigue, the side stories happening in between. This was so much fun! I can't wait for the next one!

I love this book! This is the second of the second of the penny dreadful society books and they are so very enjoyable. The inclusion of the characters' penny dreadful stories make it that much more fun. Hope there will be more!

Posted to Goodreads on 6/30

Although I didn't realize until about halfway through that this was the second book in a series, I truly enjoyed this book! The author does an incredible job developing characters as well as engaging in world building that feels authentic to the time period. The Gentleman and the Thief was an incredibly fun read, with a good mix of romance, action and mystery! I am excited to go back and read the first book!!

Note: Despite being a part of a series, this worked perfectly well as a standalone, and I had no trouble feeling engaged and excited about the characters and the plot line!

This book was so well written and intriguing and just draws the reader in. The heroine is the daughter of a merchant whose partner stole from the company, escaped with the funds and left her father to pick up the pieces. She now works for a school for urchin children and her father lives in a single room of the large house they still own. The hero is the younger son of a family who is part of the ton, but not titled. He is a secret writer of children serials and adult books and uses a 'nom de plume'. They meet at the school for urchins and they are attracted to each other. The heroine feels that she is too low in society and the hero feels that he lacks the means to support her. This sounds just like any other similar story, right? Well, keep reading because the story takes a hard left into secrets and intrigue and the reader happily follows along. I must say with all.of the story plots and twists, this author shows a master of storytelling dexterity that keeps.the story on point and makes sense. I can give a handful of authors who can't do that and I have read 4 this week so far. I will not reveal any more spoilers or cliff hangers, for I recommend that you obtain this story and read it. The twists and turns are gripping, but the plain writing of the settings and characters and realistic situations are sublime. And you know what, thinking back, I do not think there was a sex scene, or if there was, it was not the focus of the book. What a blessed change from the vapid choices that romance readers face. The characters were likeable and grew in the story. I give this book 5 stars and a hearty recommendation to read.

Recommended for fun, adventurous, clean reading - 4 STARS

This is my first time reading a book by this author and steps outside my normal choice of faith-filled stories. I thoroughly enjoyed it. Besides the book itself, there are 2 penny dreadful stories within this book. That was great fun as I found myself wanting to find out what would happen next within those!

London, 1865 - "Hollis Darby learned two things at the knee of his not-so-dear, long-departed, low-life, scoundrel of a father: how to gamble beyond what was advisable and how to be an utter disappointment to his family.

"FOR THE POOR AND INFIRM, THE HOPELESS AND VOICELESS, WE DO NOT RELENT. WE DO NOT FORGET. WE ARE THE DREAD PENNY SOCIETY."

Very Merry was a delight - "Holis dropped his face into his hands. "How often do you hide in this room?" She Shrugged. "I like scones.""

"Thieves. Missing brothers. Shady games of chance. London was many things, but it certainly wasn't boring."

I was gifted an eBook from the publisher and NetGalley in exchange for my honest opinion. All opinions are my own without compensation or further expectation.

I have already posted to GoodReads. REVIEWS WILL BE POSTED TO MY BLOG, AMZN, B&N, BAM, GOOGLE PLAY BOOKS, KOBO CLOSER TO THE NOV. 3RD RELEASE DATE. Thank you :)

What an absolute delight of a book! Sarah Eden’s The Gentleman and the Thief is a quick and enjoyable read with characters that are so well developed and likable that they’ll feel like friends, and a plot that is so well done and intriguing it’ll pull you right in. I absolutely loved the DPS and their interactions. I enjoyed Hollis and Ana’s characters, interactions, and relationship. The events in the book moved quickly, but everything made sense. The overarching conflict was an intriguing one, adding drama, suspense, and mystery.

My only gripe with this book is that it should be made clear there is a book that comes before, where you are introduced to many of the characters and to that overarching conflict mentioned above. Despite this, I didn’t really feel lost, just left out of a good story. I don’t generally go back and read a previous book if I accidentally entered at a later book, but I may just do so here, purely for entertainment. I anxiously await the next book in this series, but I will caution the author not to drag this story out too long!

Another fun Dread Penny Society novel. I love how Sarah M Eden writes in such a way that the novel and the two penny dreadfuls in the book play off of each other so it isn't hard to follow each story. I love Hollis Darby and Ana Newports characters in this book. They both have secrets to hide. I know I am in for a treat each time I open the pages of a Sarah M Eden book. I would definitely recommend.

I absolutely loved this story. Sarah M. Eden has such a way with world and relationship building, and she shows her skill throughout this story. I was both engaged in the plot and invested in Hollis and Ana's relationship from beginning to end.

Ah, yes. The characters. What to say? Hollis is pretty two dimensional, isn't he? Rather dull, right? Hah. Not even. Hollis is a brilliantly talented man who everyone overlooks due to (1) his quiet dependability, and (2) station in life. He holds a (somewhat tenuous) position in society and many in the Dread Penny Society tend to write him off as less than useful in their more active escapades. In this story we learn that there is so much more to Hollis (Mr. Lafayette Jones) than what first meets the eye. The same could be said for Ana, but I won't go into that as I don't want to spoil the fun. Let's just say she is a lady of many talents.

Facades feature prominently in the story. A number of individuals appear to be fine at a superficial level, but we learn later that they are barely hanging on, either emotionally or financially. This is a timely reminder for us today: to invest in our relationships and not depend solely on outward impressions.

It is wonderful to see relationship growth between the two brothers and to also watch the Dread Penny Society's estimation of Hollis grow as the story progresses. The story has a great payoff in the end, and I really hope we get to see Hollis and Ana in future Dread Penny Society novels. It still feels like there is more to their story, and I want it all!

Side note: there is a scene in the novel where we get to view a card sharp at work and it is absolutely fascinating! I love the details in that scene; it's fast paced and absolutely engrossing.

I cannot wait for this title to release so I can grab a copy for my collection. Such a fun read.

Thank you, publisher and author, for granting me an advance copy of this title in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.

Sarah has done it again. This novel was beautifully written. The characters we first met in The Lady and The Highwayman have returned for another great story. I appreciated the relationship that built between Hollis and Ana. I love that Sarah includes chapters containing penny dreadful written by Hollis (as Lafayette Jones) as well as a new one from Mr. King. Having these alternating chapters has been a new experience with this series from Sarah but it's been an absolute delight to experience the different stories all in one book. I loved the development of Ana's character as the story progressed.

3.5 ⭐️ out of 5 ⭐️
This was such an interesting premise. A music teacher moonlighting as a thief? A gentleman moonlighting as a penny dreadful writer/spy? Um, yes please. But to be perfectly honest this was just okay for me. They were a bit insta-lovey in some ways, but that didn't bother me toooo much.

It took me a while to get into the writing style and also I did frequently get confused by the various concurrent plots (within the penny dreadfuls and the actual)....I liked that it was trying to enrich the text and the story with what the DPS members were writing about, but I felt as though it almost detracted from the story a little bit.

Hollis and Ana were definitely well-matched and cute together, but I didn't feel as though their chemistry was as well built up as it could have been.

I will say though, that I will look into the first book in the series as I would love to see how Elizabeth first joined the DPS and got together with Fletcher!

Note: I was very kindly gifted an ARC of this novel by the publisher and author via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.

I really enjoyed this story about a gentleman hiding his true profession as a penny dreadful writer and a thief working to steal back the family heirlooms that were stolen from her. Hollis is the perfect gentleman, but he secretly spends his time with people Society has written off and works to save young children from terrible futures. Ana's family was once a part of the very Society she now works for, but when they fell on hard times, everyone turned away from her and they lost everything. She refuses to allow that to stand.

Together, these two will work to uncover truths, help those who need them, and perhaps fall in love along the way. They are adorable, and all the side characters are so great. I really enjoyed this story!

I enjoy Sarah Eden's novels and this series is especially fun because it's more lighthearted than her others. The characters are fun as is the plot. I will say that I don't necessarily enjoy the penny dreadfuls that are interspersed between the main story.

Undeniably clever, suspenseful, well-researched, and deftly written, but the romance was practically nonexistent, taking third place after the action sequences and the two penny dreadful stories. I enjoyed the hero and heroine when they were secondary characters in the previous book and feel like they deserved a better happily-ever-after than they got in this one. I also expected more resolution for the primary characters from the previous book, but nothing seemed to have changed for them. Perhaps that's more realistic and I was simply feeling more fanciful about their relationship. There are many unresolved threads hanging, although that may be because this is going to be an ongoing series. I was disappointed in the relative lack of witty dialogue that I usually so enjoy in books by this author. My expectations and excitement for this book were perhaps a bit too high, but it was still without question an interesting read.

At first, I thought it was a bit slow. But then, I looked down to see what percentage I was on and BA BAMM - I was already a third of the way through. I loved the plot of this book. Even though its a romance, there's a mystery at the core. The love story is adorable, especially with the dual-perspective.

I loved the author's choice to include the stories that Hollis and Elizabeth write! They were so cute and added a lot to the story - especially Hollis because the characters he wrote reflected his internal struggle.

My one qualm with this book is that there were so many characters and code names and I was a bit confused at some parts.

All in all, I would totally recommend this book if you're into historical fiction, cute romances, or even mysteries.

Thank you to the Publisher and NetGalley for an eARC!!

This was my first time reading anything by this author and I am so excited she has many more offerings! I’ve already added several to my TBR list and can’t wait to dive in!
This book was captivating from the very start and I couldn’t put it down. I loved the romance, the mystery, the wit of the characters and plot.
I was sympathetic to the street urchins and couldn’t help but want to see justice served and their abuser apprehended.
I loved reading the Penny Dreadful stories and I thought they were a very clever touch to an already engrossing story.
My only disappointment with this story was the fact that it is part of a series so it leaves you at a bit of a cliffhanger with not everything tied up in a pretty little package. I’ll be honest I’m not a fan of having to wait for the next book in a series to release but I do understand that it is necessary at times to fully tie a series together. For this reason I can only give four stars.
Highly recommend and I would definitely read again.
I was given this copy in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts and opinions expressed here are completely my own.

NOTE: This is book 2 in the series. It doesn't give away much, but will make more sense if you've read The Lady and the Highwayman.

***************
Miss Ana Newport is a music teacher at Thurloe Collegiate School for Girls. Her father was once a successful businessman, but his partner's poor choices resulted in a loss of the family's fortune and good standing in society. Several years after being rejected and mistreated by the ton, Ana is taking action to recover sentimental items stolen from her family.

As a long-standing member of the Dread Penny Society (DPS), Hollis Darby knows he can do more than solicit donations for their cause. When he inadvertently stumbles across a secret gentleman's club, he finally gets a chance to prove his abilities and make a difference. Meanwhile, his affection for Miss Newport grows despite learning about her past and discovering her current activities.

BONUS! Two more "penny dreadfuls" are sprinkled throughout: "The Gentleman and The Thief" by Mr. King and "Higglebottom's School for the Dead" by Lafayette Jones (Hollis Darby). While they reflect -- and occasionally foreshadow -- parts of the main story, they each have their own happy endings!

***************
The "penny dreadfuls" are so light and entertaining. Their unexpected twists kept me on my toes the whole time!

Between the "penny dreadfuls" and the emphasis on solving the mystery / catching Four-Finger Mike, the relationship between Hollis and Ana has less page time than would be expected in most romance novels. I would categorize this book as a mystery / crime-fighting novel with a hint of romance.

I loved the extension of the characters and underlying plot from "The Lady and the Highwayman"! It was fun to hear a little bit from Fletcher and Elizabeth again. I can't wait for the DPS to catch Four-Finger Mike and to learn the identities of the Dread Master and The Mastiff in future "installments"!

OVERALL
Some mild peril and very mild violence.
Language: squeaky clean!
Romance: clean; two semi-passionate kissing scenes.
Themes include: crime rings, gambling, cheating, financial ruin, theft, protecting children, keeping secrets, ghosts and mythological creatures.

Another winner in this series by Sarah M. Eden. I love the Penny Dreadfuls and the stories with just enough fanciful magic to make it fun. It is fun to sort through the three stories. It takes talent to put three stories interwoven in one book with pieces that overlap.

This book was pure enjoyment and escape for me. The mystery is really just coming together and I anticipate it reaching across the rest of the series. I loved getting richer details about characters that we were introduced to in The Lady and the Highwayman. I will certainly be adding this book to my shelves when it hits the bookstores.

The romance was perfect and fun as well. As the title suggests there is a gentleman and a thief that are truly perfect for each other and understanding of each other's flaws.

Hollis Darby may have paid his way through college with gambling, but now he makes a living by secretly writing penny dreadfuls. Gambling ruined his family and he is suspicious when his brother seems to be taking the vice up. The last thing he wants to see is his family ruined all over again. Meanwhile, he is courting Ana Newport, a music teacher who has sworn to get back what was once wrongfully taken by her family. When news of a thief leads Hollis to investigate, he is surprised to discover the sneaky thief is Ana. Together they work to bring down the illicit gambling den next door to Ana's family home.

This was a great addition to the series. Like the previous title, The Lady and the Highwayman, this also included excerpts of penny dreadfuls, one from Hollis and one from Elizabeth whose story mirrors Hollis and Ana's romance. I was happy to see those excerpts included since they were one of my favorite bits from the first book. The gambling and thief investigations also added some mystery and excitement to the romance. If you enjoyed The Lady and the Highwayman, you'll like this one.

The Gentleman and the Thief showcases Sarah Eden's masterful writing skills. With unique dialects, an immersive world, and well-written characters, this story is a great sequel to The Lady and the Highwayman. From the beginning, Hollis Darby and Ana Newport have romantic inclinations but their differences in situations create barriers that they have to circumvent as suspense, adventure, and danger threaten the world they hold dear.

Sarah Eden's books are always a favorite of mine and this one is no different. I loved how it went from the pure romance genre to adding adventure and mystery. These additions made this book page-turning (in a digital way). The skillful writing of dialogue and character perspectives added to the genre to make this one of Eden's best works. I loved reading this advanced reader's copy and can't wait for it to come out in November to share with friends and family.

Superb novel. The character development is spot on, the story arc is believable and easy to follow, and the story line engaging.

This was a sweet and fun story with loveable characters and a fascinating backstory. I loved the secret, ragtag team of short story writers who went around saving street rats and keeping the street safe. Ana and Hollis were so sweet and refreshing to read about. It is so common to find books where the main characters immediately fall in love with each other and only admire their significant others' bodies through vulgar descriptions until about 60% into the book they actually start loving each other for their personality. And while I am not berating those sorts of books or characters, it was so refreshing to read characters who genuinely respected each other and their morals and boundaries and started to fall in love with each other's personalities as they encounter each other more and more as the book progresses.

I was elated at the fact that I got three stories in one. I got to follow the penny dreadfuls written by 'Mr. King' and 'Lafeyette Jones' and also got to follow along with Ana and Hollis's story. I found myself on the edge of my seat, wanting to know what happens next for all of the stories.

The only reason I am docking a little bit more than a star of the book was how slow it was. The book doesn't really get interesting/pick up until around 60% of the book. Also, Ana being exposed as a thief comes at the 50% mark of the book and wasn't the angsty dividing factor of the romance as the description of the book made it seem, it was brushed off pretty easily by Hollis.

Overall enjoyable read

3.75 stars

I was so excited to receive an ARC of this title from Netgalley! The previous installment in this series, The Lady and the Highwayman, is probably my favorite book I have read this year and I was so excited to see Fletcher (my love) and Elizabeth back in this book. But this is not their story. It is focused on Fletcher’s best friend Hollis Darby and Elizabeth’s friend Ana Newport. Their mutual attraction began in the first book, and as this story begins, the seed of their relationship is already planted.

In The Lady and the Highwayman, my focus was on the delicious romance and the adventure, while excellent, came second. This book was the opposite. The mystery of the gambling house and Ana’s exploits at thieving were the best parts of the story. For that reason, I didn’t fall quite as in love with this story. Ana and Hollis were both a little bland. They were sweet, but they didn’t have any fire. No suspense. No will they, won’t they. Apart from writing penny dreadful, being sweet to children, and good at cards, there is nothing much that stands out about Hollis. Ms. Eden’s books are usually dripping with chemistry.

That being said, this story was so much fun. It had me cheering for the good guys, loving the servant spy network, and celebrating every time Fletch made an appearance. I can’t wait for the next one! I hope Brogan will be the hero!

3.5 stars but rounded up. This is the second in the Proper Romance Victorian series and I had read and enjoyed the first "The Lady and the Highwayman". Hollis Darby is from a wealthy family whose father and grandfather had gambled away the family fortune. He now supports himself writing penny dreadful stories that are popular with the working class. Ana Newport is a music teacher at a school. She once lived in society until her father's business ended in bankruptcy and scandal. She has her own secrets.

The story to me is more historical fiction with a romance on the side. The main plot of the story is about the Penney Dreadful Society. The authors have banded together to help children get away from being exploited by villainous characters. They are looking for a child who has been pressed into stealing. And they take on a gambling operation as well. Much of the book is focused on these plot points more than on the blooming romance of Hollis and Ana.

In addition between each chapter there is a chapter from two penny dreadful stories. One about a ghost school written by Hollis. The second about the theft of goods from a country house written by Mr. King another penny dreadful author. The first story is for fun but the second can be related back to the main story. This device was used in the first book in the series as well. It is almost like getting three stories in one. I enjoyed it more in the previous book. This time, it felt like it interrupted the flow of the narrative. But I can see the author sticking to her format throughout the series.

Overall I liked the book. The Hollis and Ana were well thought out and they worked together for a fun adventure. I appreciated seeing the characters from the previous book as well. My enjoyment was enhanced by having read the first book. This adventure could stand alone but you wouldn't understand the Dreadful Society and the work they are trying to accomplish. My biggest negative was there was no development of the romance. Hollis is smitten at first glance. But how was the feeling reciprocated? Was the difference in station considered? (It was in Mr. Kings story.) The romance was very secondary to the plot.

I always appreciate that Sarah Eden writes clean books. No steamy scenes and only a few mild curse words. Thank you NetGalley and Shadow Mountain for the eBook in exchange for an honest review.

Loved this book and looked forward to the next one! Usually I don't enjoy Regency/Victorian Romances by American authors, (they come across as too modern and American), but this one surprised me. A great Victorian Romance/Mystery.

I love how Sarah Eden weaves together the story-within-a-story aspect of this novel. It's fun and charming and the whole premise of this series in general is delightful. Though I prefer her other family series—such as the Jonquils and the Lancasters (oh and her Irish series too!)—this series is a fun showcase of her talents!

What I Loved:

The Mystery. In Gentleman and the Thief, there is a mysterious string of robberies by children who are all too afraid of their handler to name him, and a rich man’s gambling den that no one can pinpoint and leaves men destitute. The Penny Dreadful gang knows there is something up, but can’t get their finger on it because of the society. Enter Hollis, the one of their order who is of higher birth and can get them in. I thought the mystery was pretty compelling, and tied in a lot of the great elements from the first book (social justice, access to education, etc). It also showed a different side of the society we came to enjoy in Highwayman.

Hollis and Ana. While a lot of other reviewers were disappointed by the lack of romance and build up from Hollis and Ana, I thought Hollis’ love for her from the very beginning to be really sweet, and I enjoyed that the mystery and their personal lives were just as important as their budding romance. Ana, a thief trying to steal back her family’s wrongfully taken possessions, is a flawed and compelling character, and Hollis’ yearning to fit in and dry sense of humor make both of them relatable and fun to read about. They also have a very different dynamic from Highwayman’s mains Fletcher and Elizabeth, but I liked that.

The Higglebottom’s School for the Dead Interlude. The penny dreadful that Hollis is writing under nom de plume Lafayette Jones was really fun, about boy ghosts learning how to haunt properly who stumble upon a living boy. Unlike Elizabeth’s Mr. King story, which is much more parallel to the story at hand, this was light and unrelated to the rest of the plot. While the format is inconvenient (see below), Higglebottom’s was good in its own right.

What Didn’t Work So Well:

The Broken Format. I touched on this a little with the last book, but I really don’t love the way the penny dreadful stories are interspersed with the main body of the book. Both Mr. King and Lafayette Jones stories seem to begin right at a “cliffhanger” in the middle of the main story, and it ends up just being a distraction. I personally think the reading would be easier if the stories were at the end as an excerpt, but I know other readers enjoy the parallels made in the King penny dreadful.

That is really all as far as overarching complaints. I have some minor complaints about the pacing, but overall, Gentleman and the Thief exceeded expectations for the second book in this series.

Conclusion

All in all, I am so happy with how Gentleman and a Thief turned out! I think a lot of issues other readers had with it was (a) the lesser romance than in the first book, Lady and the Highwayman, and (b) the fact that this wasn’t really properly marketed as a sequel to Lady and the Highwayman. So, as someone who read both, I highly recommend reading Lady and the Highwayman first.

I have read both books in this series and, while I liked the first one, I enjoyed this one far more. If you haven't read the first book in the series, I highly recommend you do so in order to understand the background of everything happening as there is a storyline running throughout the series.

Hollis and Ana are a sweet couple that fit well together in the daylight as their public persona and work even better in the shadows with their secret selves. I always love a story where the characters are completely comfortable with and accepting of each other. This is one of those stories. The more secrets that are revealed, the more devoted they become.

As always with this series, the supporting cast is superb. They are all unique and I look forward to getting to know them better in future books.

The "penny dreadful" stories interspersed within the novel are also a unique addition and worth reading all on their own.

When I first read The Lady and the Highwayman, I was completely enthralled with Ms. Eden's new Victorian book and hoped that she would make it a series...and thank heavens she did because The Gentleman and the Thief is just as delightful!! I was so happy to return to the world of penny dreadfuls and the society that helps save children from the cruel world around them. Hollis and Ana were wonderful supporting characters in the first novel and they really shined in this second novel. I love how Hollis wanted to do more to help than the Dreadfuls originally thought he could and how Ana is anything but the prim and proper music teacher. Honestly, there isn't a thing I would change about this novel, it was an absolute delight from beginning to end.

Thank you NetGalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for the eARC!

The Gentleman and the Thief is the second in the series, and holds to the format established in the first book, where you get the book you are reading and a bonus Penny Dreadful. In this case you get two Penny Dreadfuls included! Elizabeth is a support character in this installment as we learn more about another Penny Dreadful author and his life. Hollis Darby writing unter the name Lafayette Jones has his secret society and the secret that he authors these books. While Ana has a secret about her past that is causing some interesting situations in the present. I have enjoyed this series so far. Thank you #NetGalley for the chance to offer my honest opinion on #TheGentlemanandtheThief

Ah, good old Fletcher. I know he’s not the main character of this story, but he’s still one of my favorite characters, and he stole the scene just about every time he was in one. That being said, I really enjoyed getting to know Hollis and Ana’s story this time around. It was fun to see them figure out each other’s deep, dark secrets.

Just like with the first book in this series, I really enjoyed the Penny Dreadful stories. I’m looking forward to getting to know more of the Dread Penny Society, and highly recommend this series.

As the second book in this series this book was well written. I absolutely loved it. I hope we get a book for every member of the Penny Dreadful Society!

#TheGentlemanAndTheThief #NetGalley

This is the second book in the Penny Dreadful Series. This book is like reading three books in one. There's a main story, and two Penny Dreadful Stories. Hollis Darby and Ana Newport, are both on the outskirts of society. Ana longs to help her father, feel like himself again, losing everything but his home has a way of changing her father. Hollis Darby has a secret, he is a Penny Dreadful author, trying to find his place. In society. I loved both Hollis and Ana and their adventures. This book has a little bit of mystery and romance. I really enjoyed it, this is my favorite, in the series so far.

The hero and heroine have secrets in this well-developed Victorian mystery romance.. Eden has a sure hand at creating likable characters and tangled plots.

3.5 -

This was difficult to get into and enjoy. Once you do, it's a little predictable but otherwise entertaining. It's not bad if you're looking for a historical fiction/romance/mystery book, though!

I found I really liked the previous book in the series, but this one wasn't quite as good. Eden's my favorite author so I've read nearly every one of her books. It is similar to her other works both in the plot and with the characters. I have to say, Ana was the only new/fresh character with the whole cast. Elliot was alright but he just blended in a little too well with the rest of her male characters.

As always, her pacing is quite well done. I really liked the climax. I don't think I've read a historical fiction that had a climax similar to this one ever before.

I wish she had put a specific date or even time period into her book. It would have helped me picture and put the whole story in the correct setting. From what I can tell we are past the French Revolution (1799) and sometime around the second Industrial Revolution (1870) but I'm not sure.

I did have to skip the stories included that she has her characters write. They're charming, of course, but they confused me from the main plot. I'm planning on going back and reading those eventually though. I do like the concept and idea of it. It must have been difficult to write 3 stories just for one book.

**Thank you Netgalley and the publisher Shadow Mt. for the ARC!!**

If you read the first book in the “Penny Dreadful” series and enjoyed it then chances are you will love this one as well.
I personally thoroughly enjoyed them both. I wasn’t expecting a sweeping sappy romance when I read the description I expected a mystery..... so when other people say there was very little romance I’m wondering why they were surprised. I love having the penny dreadful stories mixed in- it’s like reading 3 books at once. I was entertained and that’s the whole reason I read books so I give this book a thumbs up. Now I can’t wait for the next in the series.

***Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. Expected release date November 3, 2020.***

🌟🌟🌟🌟
4 - 4.5 stars

Shortly after receiving this ARC, I found out that this was actually the 2nd book in the Proper Romance Victorian series by Sarah M. Eden, so I went back and read The Lady and the Highwayman first. I loved the setting and the characters, so I was excited to move on to the second book.

The Gentleman and the Thief did not disappoint. I loved Hollis and Ana, and the mischief that they got into.

Can't wait for the next installment to learn more about other characters in the Dread Penny Society!! 🥰🥰🥰

Book two of "Proper Romance Victorian" by Sarah Eden. I just listened to the first book a week ago, so I had all the characters fresh in my mind and was ready to hear the next round of adventures. I liked this one even more than the first. I did enjoy reading more than listening, as it was easier to keep some of the characters straight. In this book we get to follow Hollis Darby and Ana Newport as they uncover a gambling ring, discover their less-than-proper hobbies, and see their relationship build. Hollis comes from a wealthy family that was almost ruined by his father's gambling. Ana was once a part of high society, but after her father was swindled, their family fell fast and hard. There is family intrigue, rescuing of abused children, the Dread Penny Society, and of course a sweet romance in the mix.

I loved that we are following a different set of characters each time, but still have the underlying story. I am really enjoying the Penny Dreadful books as well. Very clever stories that interweave with the story we are reading. And I especially love that it's clean!

I enjoyed this very much and look forward to the next installment!

Thank you NetGalley and Shadow Mountain for an ARC in exchange for my honest opinion!

This is the 2nd novel in the Penny Dreadful series by Sarah M. Eden. The first one was slow to get into and the incerpts of the penny dreadful serials thrown in threw me off but I loved how it tied together with the main story in the end. So knowing what I knew of the first book plus plot and characters- I was so excited to read this book!

We meet Ana and Hollis in the first book. Ana is quiet and it was great getting to know her and see her become more confident. Hollis, one to normally follow Fletcher, got to lead in a DPS mission.

Four Finger Mike eluded capture one the first book and something is going awry next door to Ana’s home. Could it be a new kingpin? Thefts have been happening to the upper crusts and in plain sight. Hollis’ brother hounds on him to uphold their family name but what about Hollis’s brother being seen with Headley? A known acquaintance of Four Fingers.

I really loved this book - all 3 stories that were told. The fantasy of the dreadfuls was fun and engaging, the returning cast of characters and meeting some new ones - I love Very Merry! Eden writes it well, so thoroughly researched that you’re transported and in Victoria England. Great suspense and romance.

The third book in the series was just announced and its Brogan’s story! Thank you to Net Galley for letting me read it. These are my own thoughts and opinions.

Hollis Darby secretly writes penny farthing novels. He is a member of the gentry, but his father impoverished the family by his gambling. Hollis secretly supports himself from his writing. Ana Newport, music teacher, has her own secrets. A few years back, Ana's family suffered financial setbacks, and society was not kind to them, and many of their treasures were stolen. Ana, has kept track of which items were stolen, and who took them, and she is slowly recovering the items. With their secrets, both Ana and Hollis are "one foot in each world, never truly part of either." Yes, this is a love story, but also a satisfying story of taking down evil men cheating others at gambling.

Sarah Eden continues the story of the Dread Penny Society members in this delightful novel, brimming with engaging characters and delightful dialogue. The two parallel stories written by the Dread Penny society are such a fun touch. In this novel, I especially enjoyed the story "Higglebottom's School for the Dead," written by Hollis Darby, under the pen name of Lafayette Jones.

Favorite line by Hollis, "My dear Miss Newport....I would wait a lifetime for you." Sigh!

This is a great addition to her Penny Dreadful series! In the first book, you get a peek at Hollis and Ana, so I was really excited to learn more about them in this book. Eden does an excellent job of balancing mystery and romance with character development. I loved this book and can't wait for the next one!

Sick of being their contact in the upper reach of society, Hollis would love nothing more than to show the Dread Penny Society (DPS) that he can be trusted more. Working to gain their trust, Hollis investigates a string of thefts that are making the young urchins of the streets more vulnerable. Which busy trying to catch this thief, Hollis becomes more acquainted with Ana Newport, the music teacher at Thurloe Collegiate.

Ana has her own wishes and secrets. She is the thief Hollis is looking for. Only stealing what was previously stolen from her and her family, Ana's foray into the world of the DPS comes at the perfect time. Working with Hollis, they come together to solve crimes and to save the streets urchins.

I loved Hollis in the first of the Dread Penny Society series, (The Lady and the Highwayman,) and couldn't wait for his story to be told! I'm happy to say that it didn't disappoint! Another win for Sarah M. Eden! The Gentleman and the Theif is a fun story set in the victorian era, in the world of author's turned crusaders. Eden does a fantastic job of making these characters come to life and providing two penny novels in the middle of the story. that works well to make the plot flow.

Overall I found the book in a slow pace in some parts,but I enjoyed it. I did like that we saw the penny dreadfuls. I found myself looking forward into reading it . Ana and Hollis together are cute . Overall I loved that Ana is getting back every thing she lost even though is by stealing. Hollis overall is wonderful on the way he is how he is a spy on the penny dreadfuls. The reasons they fell in Love was with valid reasons. I was happy that I could review the book . I recommend if you want to read If you want a cute romance novel that includes a side story in between. So you get two view points and the penny dreadful story, which I really was happy 😃 to read.

I really loved this book by Sarah M. Eden. I loved that we were brought again into the world that we saw in “The Lady and the Highwayman”. I loved getting to know the characters from that book better. I also loved the Penny Dreadful stories that were in the book. I also loved getting to know Hollis and Ana. I loved that they weren’t what they appeared to be on the outside and I loved how that was one of the things they loved about each other. I love the adventure that was in this book and how they worked to solve a mystery. I look forward to reading more books by Sarah Eden and getting to know more about the Dread Penny Society.

I received a complimentary book from publishers, publicists, and or authors.  A review was not required and all opinions and ideas expressed are my own.

The Thief and the Gentleman was an absolutely delightful read. It reminded me of a pantomime play where the audience is asked to cheer for the hero and hiss at the villain. It is advertised as a Proper Romance, which it is, but it’s also way more than that. This book is a frolicking adventure with intrigue, mystery and a healthy dose of humour. The Thief and the Gentleman doesn’t take itself too seriously and expects its readers do to the same. It is pure entertainment that even the youngest readers can safely enjoy.

Thank you NetGalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for this digital ARC copy.

An excellent mystery set in Victorian England. The hero writes penny dreadfuls and chapters of one of his and a second penny dreadful by another of the characters are interspersed with the main plot. I loved that many aspects of the plot reminded me of penny dreadfuls but in a fresh way.

I also loved the characters and the complicated plot of the book.

3.5*  In Victorian "penny dreadful" (installment or serialized stories) style, Sarah M. Eden handily weaves three tales together.  The reader is challenged to keep all the plot lines straight (and recognize reflections of the characters' strengths and insecurities from each storyline in the others) - it seemed that at times pieces got lost in the retellings.  This builds nicely on The Lady and the Highwayman, and although reading that is not a prerequisite to enjoying this story, some of the overarching goals that direct the efforts of the protagonists and the villains they work to bring down are better understood with that background knowledge.  I listened to that one on audiobook and the narrators' accents and inflections for the various characters in both books sounded in my head as I read this one.  Eden's creativity on the storylines in this book were a highlight and it is always a delight to get to know her characters better! 

I received a complimentary copy of this book.  Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

The Gentleman and the Thief
by Sarah M. Eden
Shadow Mountain Publishing
You Like Them You Are Auto-Approved
Shadow Mountain
Romance
Pub Date 03 Nov 2020 | Archive Date 17 Nov 2020

This is the second book in this series and I recommend you read the first one before reading this one. This is a charming tale of romance and intrigue. I really liked it. 3 stories in one. Thanks to Netgalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for my ARC.

4 star

A very clever and fun story! I'm usually no fan of Victorians, but this charming adventure won me over very quickly. The characters are very intriguing, and there is a hint that the book could grow into a continuing series - it would be a shame if this is not the case!

Interesting installment in this series. I liked the characters and the intrigue. Part of it had my heart pounding as I worried for Hollis and Ana. I enjoyed how the two of them figured out the involvement of the other in their secret lives. But the intrigue continues so there must be more to the series. The additional stories from the Penny Dreadfuls that Hollis secretly writes was fun. Much lighter and fun than many Penny Dreadfuls which have that name for a reason. These were more just delightful than dreadful.
This series is different than most of Ms. Eden's books with double elements in the writing of intrigue along with the romance. So it is a change of pace. I do enjoy her books.

Sex: no
Language: no
Violence: a little
*I received a complimentary ARC of this book and voluntarily chose to review it.

I loved this book! And imagine my scream when I found out this was actually the second book in a series. What?? Now I need to go back and read the first book and definitely I'm excited for the next one in the series.
The storyline was so interesting and it flowed well, the characters were really interesting to follow and the setting was just stunning. It's witty, super fun, cute, addicting and everything I enjoy in this kind of novels.
The only reason for my 4⭐ is that I expected more of the romance. But that aside, this book was a delicious treat.
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the ARC.

After hearing about how good Sarah M. Eden books were for years and years I finally picked up one of her books! I started with The Lady and the Highwayman and loved it so much that I immediately requested this one for review and it was just as good!
Pretty much from the first sentence I fell in love and it just kept getting better! The author is extremely talented at immediately drawing a reader in and fully immersing them in the story in the most organic way. One second you are in your house reading and the next you are walking the streets of London tossing a penny in the air.
I was charmed by Hollis Darby in the first book and was so excited to dive into his story. He cared deeply for those close to him and making sacrifices or putting himself in danger for them didn’t even give him pause. And Ana was kind and gracious but also had a spark in her that was fun to watch come out! I loved the relationship between the two of them, it built sweetly at the perfect pace and they were just adorable together! Their banter was also spot on, as was the banter with all of the other characters which is one of my favorite things about how the author wrote this series! I also completely adored the brotherhood of the Dread Penny Society, they were from all different walks of life but they shared a profession and a goal to help the less fortunate and it created a bond like no other. I loved the camaraderie between them that was truly like brothers and I am so hoping we get more and more stories about them! Since the big bad guy still hasn’t been caught I’m crossing my fingers that that means more books are coming!
Also the little Penny Dreadful chapters thrown in between the book’s chapters were fun and entertaining and a unique little addition!
In short this book was everything I wanted and more than I could have imagined and I am off to find more of this author’s books to read!

Ana’s family lost all it’s money to a con man and was pushed to the edge of polite society when she was young. Now she makes a living as a music teacher and plots her revenge against those who wronged her family. Hollis is a gentleman of society but just barely since his family is destitute, ruined by gambling debts of his father and grandfather. He seeks to improve his fortunes and those of others and maybe to catch the eye of a certain pretty music teacher.

The love story is sweet and has very few obstacles. Ana and Hollis grow closer as they seek to bring down a gambling ring that threatens their families.

A delightful read! Well written with some great characterisation, an engaging and thoroughly enjoyable storyline.

The Gentleman and the Thief is a sweet and fun Victorian Romance novel. I hadn’t read the first book in this series but I didn’t feel like I was at too much of a disadvantage reading the second installment. Little details would have been slightly clearer if I’d read the first, but this book could work as a standalone.

The character interaction is stellar, especially between the members of the Dreadful Penny Society. The relationship between Ana and Hollis is lovely and moves at pleasing pace. The plot is intriguing. I enjoy a riches to rags story that offers an uplifting ending.

I would recommend this novel to fans of delightful historical romance books.

Once again I read a book that was the 2nd in a series and have to go back to read the first book because the second was so good!!

I liked the premise of the book & the characters. I didn't think, at first, I would like the penny dreadfuls laced throughout but I did!! Kind of like books within books. Added a nice touch to the storyline.

Even though I hadn't read the first book, I don't think distracted too much from enjoying this one. It took me quite a ways through to realize something was a bit off.

Wondering what the next in the series brings!!

I received an ARC to prepare for this honest review.

This is a fantastic addition to the world of Penny Dreadful writers secretly working for the betterment of those less fortunate that Sarah M. Eden created, beginning with The Lady and the Highwayman. Both books can be read as stand-alones, but your enjoyment of The Gentleman and the Thief will be enhanced by having read the first. This story is one of taking pride in oneself and ones accomplishments, of courage under pressure, and of loving unconditionally. The hero wants to protect the heroine, but he never stifles her and never hold her back - he allows her to be strong and to be herself. This is turning into a very exciting Proper Romance series, and I can’t wait to see where we go next.

I received a copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

Sarah M. Eden takes us further into the life and times of the people in Victorian London and the Dread Penny Society.
Hollis Darby feels like the token high society member of the Dread Penny Society. Sure, he writes Penny Dreadful stories but feels like he gets light weight assignments in the Society.
Ana Newport works at Thurloe Girls School as the music instructor. She has secrets she doesn’t want known.
Hollis has been interested in Ana since he met her during the last doings of the society that introduced Fletcher and Elizabeth.
There is a little thief whose name is Very Merry, who makes their lives interesting. There are two Penny Dreadful stories told during the course of the book. The society continues to battle the evil men and networks they were fighting in The Lady and the Highwayman.
Hollis uses his skill in society and with cards to find a full place in the society. Hollis and Ana grow closer as befits a proper romance and knowing each other’s secrets cements their bond rather than tearing them apart.
I raced through this story. I didn’t want the pauses for the Penny Dreadful stories but I did want to know what would happen in them. A contradiction that just shows how well each portion was done.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to review this book prior to publication.

He's a gentleman by day, and a member of the Dread Penny Society by night. She's a mild-mannered music teacher by day, and a thief by night. Regardless of which identity is being represented at any given moment, they could never be together. Or could they?

Timid and unassuming--not to mention penniless--music teacher Ana Newport has a secret: she is a thief, "reacquiring" items that rightfully belonged to her family, stolen as trophies when her father went bankrupt. To her surprise and amusement, she has gained a streetname, the Phantom Fox. While she has no dreams or delusions of restoring the family's wealth, she is happy simply restoring some sentimental happiness. She is happy teaching students and working with music all day. So when Hollis Darby asks her if she would be interested in being his niece's private music tutor, she jumps on the opportunity, both for the sake of her income and that Mr. Darby has kindly offered to personally escort to and from the lessons.

Hollis Darby is a gentleman who writes Penny Dreadful novels under an assumed name, to protect his family's reputation--already damaged by generations of gambling, a reputation Hollis and his brother are desperate to restore to former glory. Hollis hasn't gambled in years, but when the Dread Penny Society takes note of a secret gambling ring--potentially led by an underling of the most dangerous man in London--Hollis must find a way in, especially when he learns his brother has already been lured into this dangerous web. Worse, he has realized that he has, unintentionally, drawn Miss Newport in as well...

The sequel to "The Lady and the Highwayman" returns readers to Victorian London and the Dread Penny Society, working to better the future of the city, particularly the poor and the orphaned. Combining mystery, subterfuge, and romance "The Gentleman and the Thief" will have readers hanging on to every word. Not to mention, waiting to get to the next installments of the stories-within-the-story, two Penny Dreadfuls--one written by Hollis, and the other by "Mr. King".

And, of course, there is brilliantly placed lingering plot threads, promising further adventures and romances, leaving readers eagerly awaiting more work from Eden.

The alternating chapters of penny dreadfuls was very unique, making it easier to become immersed in the time period. I really enjoyed the story about the ghost students! All in all, this is a good light read.

4.5*
I'm loving these Dread Penny Society books. If you're just discovering them, do yourself a favor and read them in order. There are several great characters and you get to know more about them as you read the books. I keep wondering which characters will get their own story but know that whichever ones do, the books will be fun.

There's some mystery and a touch of suspense here and there. Nothing too nail biting, but enough to keep you turning the pages faster and wanting to know what's going to happen. Are they going to get out of there safely? Will they catch the thief? Which ghost is going to win or lose? (Ok, that last one is part of one of the penny dreadful stories in the book). When will their secret identity come to light? Who is the bad guy? All these questions and more will be floating around in your head while you're reading it. Just saying.

And as an added bonus, you get three stories in one. We have the main story with Hollis and Ana alternating their POVs. Then we have two penny dreadful stories popping in throughout the book. I really have enjoyed the penny dreadfuls. Did you know that the author Sarah M. Eden has read penny dreadfuls and posted them on her facebook page? So if you don't know what a penny dreadful is, go check out more information from her on it. I'd heard about them years ago, long before this author started writing this series, but I've enjoyed seeing her create her own and put them into this series.

Hollis and Ana were so cute. I really enjoyed watching them dance around each other and trying to keep their secrets safe. And Hollis is a little bit (or maybe a lotta bit) of a flirt. He cracked me up. I was highlighting his lines when he was in a playful bantering mood and in a flirtatious mood. Loved his character. Both he and Ana had hurts from their past and I really liked watching their growth as they worked through individually and together to overcome those hurts. But I really loved the combining of their skills to root out and best the bad guy. *Cue ominous music* Duh, duh, duhhhhhhh!

I'm a fan! And the next character to have his story is Brogan. Woohooooo. Although I'm very hopeful that maybe his sister will get her story too? Or possibly she'll get some page time in his story and we'll get a couple different stories going on in that one and the penny dreadfuls. Am I making your head spin yet? Lol!

Content: Clean. Some moments of peril. Some talk of gambling dens, human trafficking and alcohol, but nothing graphic. It fits in great with the story and the time period. Some sweet kisses but nothing further than that.

I received a copy from the publisher, Shadow Mountain Publishing, via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions in the review are my own.

Happy Reading!!!

Delightful book. And I must say, much easier to follow than the first. I was more prepared for the different stories and viewpoints. Eden always has a way of drawing you in. 3.5 stars ( I enjoyed it but still love her other series more!)
Thanks for an advanced ecopy in exchange for a review.

I really enjoyed this book. I felt like it was something a little different for the genre and those differences made it an entertaining and fun read. The underlying romance throughout isn't too over the top but it's a sweet and cute love story. I especially loved how unapologetically smitten Hollis was. The penny dreadful and secret society elements gave it an extra twist and plot that I really enjoyed to what would have already been an enjoyable regency read.

First sentence: Hollis Darby learned two things at the knee of his not-so-dear, long-departed, low-life, scoundrel of a father: how to gamble beyond what was advisable and how to be an utter disappointment to his family.

Premise/plot: Hollis Darby, our hero, is a member of the Dread Penny Society, a secret society consisting of authors of penny dreadfuls. These authors are on a mission to do good--they are social justice reformers, if you will, intent on "saving" and "rescuing" the least of these. And in this second book, they are trying to solve a couple of mysteries...

One of the mysteries they are trying to solve is the identity of a thief...turns out there are many, many, many thieves in London. But there's one thief in particular that is hiding in plain sight.

Ana Newport, our heroine, is a music teacher by day and a thief by night...but she's not your ordinary thief. She just wants to track down all her family's belongings that were wrongfully taken...and if she just so happens to fall in love with a gentleman like Hollis Darby...well...that would be quite unexpected and lovely.

But that's just the barest fraction of the plot in this newest Victorian Proper Romance. There is a BIGGER mystery to solve--which I think in part began in the first book--and I think this bigger mystery may take more than a couple books to solve.

One of the highlights for me, however, is the inclusion of TWO serial penny dreadfuls. One serial series is Higglebottom's School for the Dead written by "Lafayette Jones" and The Gentleman and the Thief by "Mr. King."

The Gentleman and the Thief is the sequel to The Lady and the Highwayman.

My thoughts: I love, love, love, love, LOVE this series. I expected to love it of course. I adored the first book in the series. Both books are just fantastic. Highly recommended.

I really love the framework of the novel. It alternates narrators between Hollis and Ana. Both fabulous narrators, by the way, I love getting romance from both a his/her perspective. And this romance had just the right amount of challenges. It also alternates chapters or installments of the two penny dreadful series. I honest LOVED both of these. So well written. So enjoyable. So satisfying. I never once got annoyed that the plot was getting interrupted. Everything was delightful.

I truly love these unique stories. The Dread Penny Society-on the surface... Writing Penny Dreadfuls, books for the lower class.... But underneath and in secret.... Helping the lower class citizens.
In this book, there are a lot of thefts going on about Town. Most are little street urchins, doing the bidding of an unknown Master. There is also the elusive Phantom Fox.

Hollis and Ana try to navigate a budding relationship - each with their own secrets that they have to try to keep hidden.

Hollis could quite possibly beat Fletch (from the previous book) as my favorite DPS gentleman! He is so sweet and really helps the secret society he's involved with navigate London society.
Ana is a master at anything she puts her mind to! She's also very sweet and kind hearted. She is doing what she feels right after her father loses the family's standing in society. Her father is this gentle and kind guy.

I think my favorite Penny Dreadful story (which you get in between the big story) is the first school one. That one is so fun!

I always find Sarah Eden's books entertaining. This one is no exception. I did get a little confused trying to follow 3 plot lines at the same time. I think I would have prefered more time with Hollis, Ana, and company and less time in the Penny Dreadful stories. Still, it is cleaver how the stories are reflections of one another. Ana's undercover activities are quite shocking for a woman of her era. I enjoyed seeing Hollis and Ana learn to open up and trust one another. It will be fun to see how this series continues to unfold.

Readers, beware: The Dread Penny Society is back in town. Their mission this time? Justice. In September 2019, acclaimed Regency author, Sarah M. Eden, published her first book in the “Dread Penny Society” series. Titled The Lady and the Highwayman, this novel is a tongue-in-cheek - albeit romantic - take on the classic highwayman legends. Her latest addition to the series, The Gentleman and the Thief, no longer features a dashing highwayman, yet these new heroes equally hide their true selves amongst the shadows.

“For the poor and infirm, the hopeless and voiceless, we do not relent. We do not forget. We are the Dread Penny Society.” (Location 1582)

Hollis Darby: Gentleman, man about town, and member of a secret society. Now in his thirties, he is more than satisfied with his work as a writer of children’s fiction. He even finds fulfillment in his other passion -- helping to give hope to those living on the streets in his city. What Hollis lacks is a partner in crime, or at least, his brand of it. When he meets the enchanting Miss Newport, he is dazzled by her confidence, music skills, and kindness. Above all, he feels as if they are kindred spirits. Little does he know just how similar they are.

As he slipped from view, Ana opened her violin case. It was the perfect excuse and the perfect pretense. She opened the small compartment where she stored her rosin and her polishing cloth. She tucked underneath them what she’d come to this musicale for and had, by a near miracle, managed to secure: a single silver bracelet. (Location 251)

Ana Newport: Musician, survivor, and thief. After her family’s wealth and honor were destroyed years ago, Ana has taken it upon herself to learn the thief’s trade in order to reclaim her family’s possessions that were stolen from her. Under the guise of the Phantom Fox, Ana successfully separates her life in the daytime from that of the night. That is, until the charmingly perceptive Hollis Darby arrives, with his own secrets in tow.

“Courage, Miss Newport,” he whispered. “You are equal to this.” (Location 553)

As secrets are brought to light and their own demons raise their ugly heads, Hollis and Ana struggle to make the world a better place. The question is: if they work together, will they succeed? Or will they lose everything good that they’ve fought for?

Something Sarah M. Eden does remarkably well with The Gentleman and the Thief -- and The Lady and the Highwayman before it -- is the interplay of story within a story. Hollis’ serial about young thieves and their struggles provided an intriguing backdrop to his own experiences with Ana. Despite the topics of justice, revenge, and thievery, this was a surprisingly light book, filled with plenty of humor and romance to suit any reader looking for a fresh look at the Victorian period.

What I didn’t like about this book was the level to which I had to suspend my disbelief. The premise of a hidden society of mismatched, penny-dreadful novelists in the 1860s coming together to banter in Dickensian accents as they try to figure out how to bring about justice -- legally but secretly -- was too improbably naive for my taste. Ana especially was a challenge to root for, as her thievery took a weird form, masked under a pure cause. She refused to steal other people’s items, as a truly impoverished person would do. Instead, she stole to get revenge for her family’s loss of money and status, taking items that were originally hers. An ethical quibble wasn’t the main reason for my dislike, although most people (myself included) agree stealing is wrong; it was that I couldn’t get behind Ana’s motive. What was even the end goal? A small feeling of revenge, the size of a bracelet? This seemed like the kind of twisted logic villains are known for, not heroes.

That being said, Ana and Hollis were (largely) sympathetic leads, and I couldn’t help but admire their genuine compassion for those less fortunate, especially children. Both characters wanted to do something to help save the day, and while this doesn’t always work out as perfectly in real life as it did in the book, that fact doesn’t make The Gentleman and the Thief’s ending any less sweet.

Overall, The Gentleman and the Thief is a strong addition to “The Dread Penny Society” series. With its expanded world, driven characters, and message of hope despite circumstances, this is a novel that brings something new to the Victorian genre.

The Gentleman and the Thief by Sarah M. Eden was my first read by this author, and what a great read it was! I really enjoyed this story! I love the premise and the characters. It’s a nice clean romance with a great mystery that keeps you turning pages! I can’t wait for more in this series!

Thank you to NetGalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for the opportunity to read and review this book!

When they will cross path at the most unexpected place, will it be the end or beginning of them ...

I did not know well I would read this book when I requested it, for sure just a few days prior its release date.
And today being Halloween, in fact hazard could not have chosen a better schedule.
Having not read the previous book, I feared at a time, I would be lost, but the heroes in this one were side characters in the first story.
And what was my surprise when I read extract of the hero’s work, tales about a ghost boy full of mischiefs. But it does not stop there as the book is interspersed with pieces of the other Penny Dreadful authors as their respond to the mainline plot.
It added so much fun to the plot.
Hollis is from the upperclass, alas only in appearance as only his family’s name is what is left to be seen.
What an unconventional read, I wanted to learn the outcome of every different parts in this book, the two penny dreadful tales and the major plot.
Hollis is such a charming gentleman, living in between two worlds, a writer under a pen name, a member of a secret society helping the poorer and weaker but also the bearer of a name known as respectable when everything is in fact shabby in the background.
Ana has known the reverse of fortune like Hollis, but her family’s shame was made public, so she can’t hide like him. But while regaining her good name is an impossibility, she can still retrieve what was wrongly stolen from her home.
Her robbery exploits are not about retribution but mending past wounds.
Their romance is a slow burn one, none has doubt about their feelings but their own unsure position in society is what kept them holding back, until circumstances put them more than one time on the same path. Once trust is won, matter will settle very much easier.

I loved too the group of friends they navigate with, thick as thieves, their bickering is as fun as Hollis and Ana’s banter. And Very Merry is a marvel of mischiefs and lost innocence.

A much enjoyable romance with a dash of mystery.
5 stars

I was granted an advance copy by the publisher Shadow Mountain, here is my true and unbiased opinion.

From the moment Hollis Darby meets Ana Newport, he's smitten. Even though he's from a wealthy, established family and she isn't. They both have secrets he supports himself by writing penny dreadfuls under a pseudonym & at night she assumes the identity of 'The Phantom Fox' breaking into homes to reclaim treasures she feels were unjustly stolen from her family. When Hollis's brother needs to hire a music tutor for his daughter Eloise, Hollis recommends Ana, giving him a chance to spend time with her. Ana needs the income and is eager for the opportunity to get to know the enigmatic gentleman. They are then drawn to working together to help Hollis’ brother who has been gambling & in seeking out The Mastiff.
This is the second book in the series & several threads are ongoing so I’d recommend reading that first. As with the first book there are snippets from penny dreadfuls throughout the book, which for me added to the enjoyment. I really liked both Hollis & Ana but felt their romance was second fiddle to the ongoing mystery involving The Mastiff. I did find the book very hard to put down & now eagerly await the next in the series
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read

The Gentleman and the Thief is the second book in Sarah M. Eden's absolutely charming The Dread Penny Society series. The first one had an interesting setup - penny dreadful stories interwoven with the main story. It really worked there, but was it a fluke? It's an unusual premise... But no, not a fluke! This second volume was just as captivating as the first.

Hollis Darby comes from a good, wealthy family...except the family is no longer wealthy. To support himself, he writes penny dreadfuls under a pseudonym. He is also a member of the Dread Penny Society, a secret organization that helps children of the streets and other unfortunates. When he meets music teacher Ana Newport, he is immediately taken with her. But Hollis isn't the only one with secrets - by night Ana is the "Phantom Fox", a thief who breaks into the homes of the wealthy to regain sentimental trinkets which were stolen from her family unjustly. Can a romance be built upon secrets? And when they join forces to find evidence of wrongdoing in a gambling den, will they even make it out alive?

This story was utterly delightful! I just adored Hollis and Ana individually, but they were even more captivating together. Hollis wanted a more important role in the Dread Penny Society. While others were out fighting injustice, Hollis? He went to parties. It was an essential job, but parties? I could understand his frustration. Ana was a music teacher when she wasn't being the Phantom Fox. She wanted to recapture treasured items stolen when her father lost his business and hoped to help the broken man rejoin the land of the living. Hollis is totally drawn to Ana, and she to him. Together they were amusing and oh, so sweet. Don't mistake sweet for boring, however; you could feel their attraction. I couldn't help but smile at their banter. It was fun revisiting characters from the first book. What really made this book fun, though, are the penny dreadful stories woven together with Hollis and Ana's story. One story was written under Hollis's pseudonym about a school for ghosts, while the other penny dreadful shadows our hero and heroine's romance. I hope we will be honored with many more adventures of the Dread Penny Society!

I received an ARC of this book courtesy of the publisher and NetGalley. I received no compensation for my review, and all thoughts and opinions expressed are entirely my own.

The Gentleman and the Thief by Sarah M. Eden is a great read. I enjoyed every minute of this fun story and very much appreciated the escape it afforded me this week. The characters in this novel are the best! From upper-crust elites to devastatingly poor street urchins, and those with hearts of gold willing to do whatever it takes to save the lives of those less fortunate to those who relish belonging to the seedy underbelly of London society, this novel truly portrays a unique and well-crafted cast of characters sure to delight any reader. Hollis and Ana, our hero and heroine, clearly have chemistry very early on but are hesitant to declare their feelings because both are keeping some BIG secrets. But as they spend more time with one another, as they grow more comfortable in each other’s company, their relationship blossoms into something genuinely sweet and realistic. In addition to the excellent characters, I was thrilled to read more penny dreadful serials. In this novel readers are treated to two new installments — one a delightful romantic mystery and the other a super fun ghost story. I found myself as excited and engaged in these serials as I was in the main story.

Hollis is an excellent hero with a relatable issue. He is a full-fledged member of the Penny Dreadful Society, but because he’s not originally from the mean streets as the other members are he often feels like the outsider. And, it doesn’t help matters that his fellow PDS members only see him as a socialite. But what’s really frustrating to Hollis is that he doesn’t really belong to the upper-crust set either as his family coffers are basically empty. Hollis is a man without a place and he just doesn’t feel like he fits in anywhere — that is until he meets Ana. What I appreciate about Hollis is his need to be seen for who he truly is. Too often we judge others by what we see or hear, or by first impressions only, and we never really get to know the true person. What a shame this is! How many friendships might we be missing out on because we judge too hastily?

The Gentleman and the Thief is a fantastic Historical Romance/Suspense novel I highly recommend. It’s engaging, it’s fast-paced, and it’s so much fun. Purchase yourself a copy today — you won’t be disappointed that you did!

I received a review copy of this novel in eBook form from the publisher, Shadow Mountain Publishing, via NetGalley. In no way has this influenced my review. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.

3.75/5 ✨

This novel had many aspects that I really enjoyed: it had a lovely cast of characters, a swoonworthy and very cute romance and a mystery element that kept it interesting. If you’re looking for a sweet historical romance that’s more 🥰 and less 🔥, this one’s for you!
The Dread Penny Society is a group of authors who secretly fight for the social and political causes of their working-class readers and it’s what connects all of the books in this series. So I first loved the idea that some of the characters’ works that they sell were included in The Gentleman and the Thief but two different stories kinda just made the book drag a bit. I personally think that one story would’ve been enough.
However, The Gentleman and the Thief was an enjoyable and very sweet read.

Thank you to Shadow Mountain Publishing for providing an eARC through NetGalley!

This book was refreshing just as the characters were. Eden does a great job coalescing the writing style of the set era with the story line, and although it took some getting used to on my part, by the book's end, I was reading freely and felt fully immersed in the time period. Doing so is difficult, and I applaud Eden for her successful attempt. The plot itself is unique, and offers a unique, romantic take on a plot line that reminds of the web-series Purple Hyacinth. Again, a great read and a great pick-me-up from a book slump. Would definitely recommend to friends and family interested in the time period or just a fun read in general.

What a fun way to weave together the romance, adventure, and mystery! It was lovely for Hollis and Ana to develop a relationship and have that foundation as they become more involved in the investigation together, and the complications that arise with their own secrets. I enjoyed their banter and flirting, and the gentlemanly manners of Hollis. The author brought the Victorian era to life, and there is no mistaking it for another! The little details and historical tidbits are fascinating and really establish the setting. I love the idea of a secret society whose mission is to help the helpless and rescue those in need. It makes them seem like superheroes in a way, but all too human. While the entertaining excerpts from the penny dreadful stories are interspersed throughout the book, I found myself anxious to return to the main plot and read quickly to see what would happen next. An exciting addition to the series and a wonderful cast of characters!

Disclosure statement: A complimentary copy of this book was provided from a tour group, publisher, publicist, or author, including NetGalley, OR was borrowed from the library, including OverDrive, OR borrowed from Kindle Unlimited, OR purchased. A review was not required and all views and opinions expressed are unbiased and my own.

Ana and Hollis are both impoverished members of the gentry. Ana teaches music at a girls' school, while Hollis writes penny dreadfuls under a pseudonym. While Hollis still maintains the facade of respectability, thanks to an older brother who's working to restore the family name and finances, Ana's family has been ruined by scandal. Ana is determined to take back what was stolen from her family, even if that means adopting a secret life as a thief.

This novel deals with serious subjects, yet the writing style is light, fun, and engaging. I enjoyed the mix of intrigue and romance. This is my first book by Sarah M. Eden, but I'm looking forward to reading more.

I love the idea of romantic historical mysteries focusing the plot on the infamous Penny Dreadful. The mystery was engaging but not too scary more along the lines of a cozy mystery. The characters Hollis and Ana are excellent I love their chemistry and when the secret identity will be revealed. I loved the addition of the short stories the author added from the perspective of her characters. I thought it really added to the setting of novel, especially since they are penny dreadful writers. Overall, The Gentleman and the Thief is an excellent addition to The Dread Penny Society, filled with intrigue, engaging characters and romance.

I have really enjoyed this series. Book two in the Penny Dreadful Society picks up with Hollis and Ana. I loved being able to reading of their adventure that ends with a great HEA. The penny dreadful stories mixed throughout is so clever and incredibly talented! Another winner from Sarah Eden!

Disclosure statement:
I receive complimentary books for review from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, including Netgalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.

3.5 stars
Though this can be read as a stand-alone, I strongly suggest reading the first book in the series before this. I hadn’t and found the beginning confusing as I tried to understand what Dread Penny Society was, and who all the characters were.
The novel focuses on a group of Penny Dreadful authors and their exploits as the Dread Penny Society, a secret organization intent on making Victorian London safer for those in the lower classes. One such member is an aristocrat named Hollis Darby, who is determined to prove he’s more useful to the group than simply their ticket to attending society balls and soirées. As he investigates the Phantom Fox, a thief known to sneak into wealthy houses and steal items under their owner’s noses, he finds himself falling for Ana Newport, a music teacher who’s father has fallen on hard financial times. While he has secrets, gentleman aren’t supposed to earn their livings writing whimsical stories after all, he discovers that perhaps Ana has secrets of her own.
I found the blurb very misleading. It hints at them playing cat and mouse and that’s not what I got. Though it’s present briefly in the beginning, the story quickly diverts into catching a gambling ringleader who’s also involved in other unsavoury criminal activities.
There’s more emphasis placed on the mystery aspect of the novel than the romance. And while I did enjoy watching the Dread Penny Society chase criminals and protect those who are unable to protect themselves, the novel fell short awakening any sparks between Hollis and Ana. Their relationship progressed way too quickly for me to have any investment in them. That said, I didn’t dislike them together. I thought they had cute moments, but ultimately I was indifferent to them. Maybe my opinion will change after I’ve read book one.
Along with the main mystery romance plot, we also get little chapters from two of the Penny Dreadful stories. Their tone differs immensely, one being geared towards children and while the other being more romantic, that it did draw me out of the main story line.
While I realize this review makes it sound like I didn’t enjoy this book, I did. I liked the mystery aspect, the friendships between the Dread Penny Society, especially between Hollis, Fletcher, and Brogan. I just wished there was more romance than what we got.
I’m still interested in reading more by Sarah M. Eden.

Please note: I received an advance digital copy of this book through NetGalley from Shadow Mountain Publishing and Sarah M. Eden in exchange for a honest review. This does not influence my opinions in any way.

I was very impressed with this book- it was the perfect blend of mystery, romance, and fun. When I first saw “Penny Dreadful” in the series title, I was a tad worried that it would be bloodier or more violent than I would choose. However, Eden has played on the concept to make it less terrifying but still as thrilling. Ana and Hollis both lead double lives, and make for some of the most fascinating characters. Though they come from fairly different backgrounds, they are more similar than they originally realise. It makes for a sweet and enjoyable romance, but that doesn’t distract from the mystery at hand!

One aspect of this book that I really loved was the Penny Dreadful chapters. It was almost like reading an extra book, which is always a lovely feeling. It felt like we were getting more insight into Hollis as a writer, as well as the universe as a whole.

I was slightly concerned that being the second book in the series, I might be lost without having read the first. However, that wasn’t a problem at all. (I have added it to my reading list, though! And the third coming out, as well.) Like many mystery series, it can absolutely be read as a standalone book.

The thing that is fun about this book is the you get three stories. One is the main story and it has romance and intrigue. The other two are fun penny dreadful stories. One is about a ghost school for boys and the other is about 2 friends and a mysterious thief.

I knew I was in for a treat when I saw that Sarah M. Eden had written another story about the Dread Penny Society, and I was right. The Gentleman and the Thief has an old-timey, Victorian feel and is filled with delightful surprises, mystery, and adventure. The two Penny Dreadful stories included added to the pleasure.

Hollis had the appearance and manners of the perfect gentleman. Yet the company he keeps and the secret activities he engages in might belie that image. All he wants is for the Dreadfuls to allow him to be more than just a pretty face in the Society, allowing him the opportunity to do something truly useful. And little did he expect the opportunity would present itself in the manner in which it did!!

I loved the characters! Very Merry, the seven-year-old urchin, was quite possibly my favorite. Which, I suppose, just makes sense because she stole the hearts of everyone she came in contact with.

As the DPS continues its work to rescue the afflicted, they are again confronted with the evils in the city of London. It was such an adventure!

The Gentleman and the Thief is a continuation of the saga that started in The Lady and the Highwayman. Each story has a clear ending and yet leaves the mysterious man who is responsible for the crime and mayhem at large in the shadowy streets of London. You will want to read the entire Proper Romance Victorian series, in order.

Oh boy how I love historical fictions and this one was another great one. I love the characters and the beauty of how they where written. They each carried a unique quality about them. I just get excited thinking about this book again, it was so good. I cant wait to read more of Sarah work too. So happy to have found another historical author.

This series is a lot of fun and to get the full effect, I would recommend reading them in order. I love the little "penny dreadful" stories wrapped up in the middle of this book, and along with the main story, the reader is treated to two penny dreadfuls. A "penny dreadful" is a story that costs a penny and was full of adventure, danger, crime, and romance. These clever little diversions are an amusing part of the book.

A secret society is created to help those who need help and to rid society of evil and I'm enjoying the adventure of getting to know different characters in more depth. There are all kinds of personalities, backgrounds, and professions in this group, but that's what makes it work so well. Eden always does a great job of creating likable characters in entertaining situations.

Ana and Hollis are great characters and I loved the mysteries and mild suspense surrounding their interactions. It's especially fun to watch what happens when they join forces. It's apparent a lot of research has gone into this series and it's refreshing to read a bit of history written in such unique way.

Content: mild romance; mild adventure/violence/danger

Hollis and Ana were so cute together! She was a bit like the anti heroine, seeing as she was the thief. But yet, she wasn’t. It was sweet to watch them with each other. Both were a little unsure. I loved it.

I look forward to the coming books in this series. I enjoy these sweet romances without them being preachy. It was nice to have the butterflies in the belly feelings again.

I'm a romance girl through and through, so I wanted that swoon factor and I missed that in this book. To me, there wasn't enough of a build in that relationship. I cared more about Hollis and Ana achieving their individual goals than I cared about them being together.

Throughout the book, readers are given snippets of penny dreadful novels. At first, this kind of threw me, but I found myself caring just as much about the novels as I did the storyline. It's like getting three stories for the price of one and I ended up enjoying it.

Overall, I became attached to the Dread Penny Society and will likely read the rest of the series. If you're a fan of historical romances with a touch more intrigue, this one is for you!

I received a complimentary copy of this novel from the publisher. All expressed opinions belong to me.

The Dread Penny Society is a secret society in Victorian London that helps people that are trapped in the underworld of society. This includes poor children who are used as thieves and are not able to have a decent upbringing. Many of the members are also authors of “penny dreadfuls.” Penny dreadfuls were cheap serialized sensational stories that were sold for a penny during Victorian times. They were entertainment for the masses but were generally looked down upon by the upper crust.

The “Gentleman” of this story is Hollis Darby. His grandfather lost their family fortune by gambling and he and his brother are trying to use their respectable name to put the family back on solid footing again. Hollis makes money by writing penny dreadfuls secretly at night. He meets and falls in love with Ana Newport. Ana is a music teacher at a school for girls. Her family lost their fortune when her father’s business partner stole from their company. She also has a secret. At night she is the “phantom fox” and steals the items back that were stolen from her family. As Hollis and Ana get to know one another, they start to investigate the strange activities at her neighbor’s home. Why are there gentleman visiting the home at all times of day and night? Why has her old neighbor suddenly moved away? Who is behind all of the robberies that are taken place across London?

I loved The Gentleman and the Thief. The plot was very exciting and suspenseful. I really liked the mysteries and trying to determine what was going on. I also really liked that the overall goal of the characters was to help out those in trouble. I enjoyed the characters, especially the main characters of Hollis and Ana. I especially liked that interspersed throughout the novel were chapters from penny dreadfuls. One was the story of a school for ghosts and the other was the story of a gentleman that keeps finding items missing from his him. He enlists the help of his childhood friend, the steward’s daughter, and together they tackle the mystery. I especially loved this second story.

The Gentleman and the Thief is the second novel in the Dread Penny Society books. I read this as a standalone and it worked. I would love to read the first book in the series, The Lady and the Highwayman. I’m adding it to my “to read” list. I also enjoyed that this story was a clean romance.

Overall, The Gentleman and the Thief is a riveting story of love and danger in Victorian London. I highly recommend it!

Book Source: Review Copy from Shadow Mountain Publishing for being a part of the Blog Tour. Thank-you!

What a cute story! I loved the first book in the series and so couldn't wait to read more. Each chapter has an installment from the penny dreadful. It is like reading multiple stories in one book. I am so impressed with Eden's ability to make the stories sound like they are written by other people. Well written and highly entertaining.

I liked revisiting familiar characters and returning to London in the 1800s. We follow the members of the DPS (Dread Penny Society) as they rescue and protect street urchins through a network of spies. I love this heroic aspect, which lends hope amidst a backdrop of dank London streets.

The main characters are often writers of “penny dreadful,” stories mainly for children with daring heroes and mysteries or even ghosts/zombies, etc. I admit I’ve skimmed or skipped these aspects at times. There are hidden elements if you want to read them, but I haven’t felt I’ve missed out by skimming.

It’s impressive to me that the author includes these stories in her narrative while also carrying out the main story of the novel as the penny dreadful excerpts are themselves detailed and layered.

Our heroine is multi-layered as well. She’s committing crime for noble reasons, and no one suspects her. This aspect really hooks readers.

The chemistry between the hero and heroine was delightful. Sarah is one of my favorite authors of historical fiction. I love her sense of humor and how she includes it on the page.

I do recommend reading these novels in order. The first is The Lady and the Highwayman. The Gentleman and the Thief is the second book in the Dread Penny Society series.

I enjoyed my time reading this delightful story. This charming, page turning mystery set in Victorian England is sure to not only entertain your imagination, but keep you up late into the night sipping tea and turning pages. I especially enjoyed the fun banter between the characters.

I enjoyed watching these characters growth in this story, both as individuals and together. Sarah Eden weaves an enchanting story with a rich plot and engaging characters and I simply did not want to put this story down. A light, fun mystery that is sure to entertain!

This is the second book in the series, and I need to go back and read the first book. However, I caught up fairly quickly and didn’t feel that my not reading the first book put me at too great of a disadvantage.

(I receive complimentary books for review from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, including Netgalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own.)

Hollis and Ana. So many secrets, but together they form a formidable and entertaining team. I love that they are from different stations in life as it offers different perspectives and points of view. Bring your focus factor as there is more than story occurring and you don’t want to get lost in the details. The descriptions of London in the mid-1800s are enlightening and transport you to the scene. The mystery, intrigue and chemistry will charm and satisfy lovers of historical fiction. This is book two in a series from Sarah M. Eden, but easily stands alone.
I received a complimentary copy from NetGalley and all opinions expressed are my own, freely given.

Had to read the first one first but love them both! Very entertaining and fun. I love a regency novel and this one had good characters and dialogue.

"A gentleman scribes penny dreadful novels by night and falls in love with a woman who is a music teacher by day - and a thief at night.

LONDON 1865

From the moment Hollis Darby meets Ana Newport, he's smitten. Even though he's from a wealthy, established family and she isn't, he wishes he could have a life with her by his side. But Hollis has a secret: the deep coffers that have kept his family afloat for generations are bare, so he supports himself by writing penny dreadfuls under a pseudonym. If not for the income from his novels, he would be broke.

Ana Newport also has a secret. Though she once had a place in society thanks to her father's successful business, bankruptcy and scandal reduced his fortune to nothing more than a crumbling town house. So Ana teaches music during the day, and at night she assumes the identity of the "Phantom Fox." She breaks into the homes of the wealthy to reclaim trinkets and treasures she feels were unjustly stolen from her family when they were struggling.

When Hollis's brother needs to hire a music tutor for his daughter, Hollis recommends Ana, giving him a chance to spend time with her. Ana needs the income and is eager for the opportunity to get to know the enigmatic gentleman. What neither of them expects is how difficult it will be to keep their respective secrets from each other.

When a spree of robberies rocks the city, Ana and Hollis join forces to solve the crimes, discovering that working together deepens the affection between them. After all, who better to save the day than a gentleman and a thief?"

I love female thieves and penny dreadfuls! Was this book written just for me?

The Gentleman and The Theif

Hollis and Ana have a lot in common. They both have been through so much and both are so strong.

Hollis is living a double life in away. He appears to a fine Gentleman to everyone around him in society. If people find out he is apart of the PDS they won’t thinks so highly of him.

Ana has lost everything. She works at Thurloe Collegiate School. She too is living a double life. She has a secret that could hurt the job she has.

I love the {PDS} Penny Dreadful Society. This a group of amazing people doing great work for those that are less fortunate or who can’t help themselves.

I love how the stories the {PDS} write are intertwined into the book.

This is such a wonderful book. I throughly enjoyed every minute of it. It is full of adventure, mystery and romance. Sarah M. Eden has away of pulling you right in to the story from the first paragraph. This is only the 3 book of hers I have read. I have loved each one!!


{ I received ARC from the publisher through NetGalley }

#BookLove

I love the Dread Penny Society. It is made up of a group of eclectic personalities that write Penny Dreadfuls and strive to make society a better place for the less fortunate.

This story is about Hollis Darby, a gentleman and a member of the Dread Penny Society. He is out to save the world while pretending to be a man of leisure. He is devoted to his cause, friends, and family.

Hollis has a mystery to solve. There is a thief that is making life harder for the street urchins he is concerned about. It is something that he wants to get to the bottom of while finding himself attracted to Ana, a music teacher at a girl's school the Dreadfuls have a vested interest in.

The book has many moments that make you laugh, smile, and teach about the plight of the less fortunate during Victorian London. I enjoyed the story and the stories within the story. There are chapters that are Penny Dreadful stories. It is a unique feature that I enjoy.

The characters are wonderful and the story is well-paced. Sarah Eden is one of my favorite authors and this book is one that I would love to revisit.

Source: I received a complimentary copy. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own,

This was an interesting story. I absolutely love this author and have ready many of her books and loved them. This was kept you on your toes, though, because there were three stories in one. It is the second in the series. It isn't my favorite of hers, although, I really enjoyed reading each of the stories but it was a little confusing bouncing around between the three stories while reading, especially since I read late at night.

For the most part, I still love reading this author's work and look forward to many wonderful stories to come.

This was a clean, romantic, suspenseful story with many, many layers.

I was given an arc copy of this book and I willingly offer my honest review.

This book was delightful! Sarah always gives a stellar book 2 to her newest series! I loved the characters and the whole storyline was wonderful! You won’t regret it!

Sarah M. Eden is one of my favorite historical romance authors. Her books never fail to delight! This one had a bit more mystery and intrigue than other books of hers that I recall. I loved the historic details, especially the parts about the penny dreadfuls. We actually get three stories in one; two penny dreadful tales are spaced out one chapter at a time between chapters of the 'real' story. The Penny Dreadful spy network was fascinating too. The ending wraps most things up, but I have a feeling this will perhaps be a series (hopefully!).

Thanks Netgalley for the ARC! All opinions are my own and are unbiased.

I was not familiar with this series, but I am glad I found them. I read The Lady and the Highwayman which I throughly enjoyed. This second book was no different. I enjoy the storyline and characters. I like how the penny dreadfuls are included. Hope this series continues because we need to know who the Dread Master is!

Thank you to NetGalley for allowing me to read this book in exchange for my honest review.

It's no secret that I'm a huge Sarah Eden fan and I love her new series!

The Gentleman and the Thief features Hollis Darby, part of the Dread Penny Society who secretly try to help those in need. Hollis has secrets of his own, however. He's a gentleman in society, yet his family's coffers are bare. In order to keep up appearances, he writes Penny Dreadfuls under a pseudonym. (The stories are interspersed throughout the book, which is an added bonus. It did distract me from the main story a bit. I wish the Penny Dreadfuls were just all together at the end.) But beyond that, I loved Hollis's character and seeing his background as he tries to navigate the life he's chosen. There are so many sides and such a depth to our hero. Ms. Eden is so talented at truly bringing her characters to life and making them feel so real!

Ana Newport is such a surprise as a character. She's a thief and I loved having her be the Phantom Fox. The reasons she had resorted to stealing are heartwrenching and I was definitely rooting for Ana to have a happy ending. The interactions between Ana and Hollis are so swoon-worthy as they discover and fall in love with each other. I do admit I was turning pages as fast as possible to see how they would react when their secrets were revealed and how it would all end. Ms. Eden does not disappoint. The romance and the intrigue of the story kept me up far past my bedtime and I went back to read my favorite parts the next day! I can't wait for the next installment of the series.

This book was such a lovely sequel to The Lady and the Highwayman, and I was so happy that we got Ana and Hollis’s story. I think that was part of the reason why I enjoyed this book so much,,, I am not sure if I would have stuck with the story line had I not already been introduced to the characters. That being said, I am so glad I did, because once you get into the plot and past the first few chapters, the plot picks up and I could not put the book down. Overall, a sweet, romantic, clean continuation of The Dread Penny Society. Not as good as the first book, but I can’t wait for the third!

Fun read. Eden never disappoints!!

I received an advance reader copy in exchange for a fair review.

After reading The Lady and the Highwayman I knew I wanted to get my hands on the second in the series as soon as possible! Sarah M. Eden has done it again bringing us the story of Hollis Darby and Ana Newport in The Gentleman and the Thief. I think my favorite aspect of these stories are the Penny Dreadful inserts we get throughout the book. In this case, we are getting a story that Hollis is writing. They are such a nice little extra that pulls you in. We are also following him on a search for the "Phantom Fox" when a number of robberies are happening around town. Mystery and romance ;)

The Dread Penny Society continues with Hollis and Anna's story in helping the neglected, exploited, and abused. There were so many plots intertwined throughout along with two Penny Dreadfuls that I was never bored.

Hollis is a wealthier member of the DPS and his main job is to get funds from other members of society, but he is wanting to do more and be part of the action. Anna is still working with Elizabeth, but is on her own secret mission. It is instant attraction for Hollis and Anna at the beginning, but there are moments throughout when their love and understanding of one another deepens.

This book was entertaining with the banter between the DPS members and between the urchins and the adults while still maintaining the realities of gambling dens, child abuse, exploitation, thief masters, and thievery. Anyone who enjoys Sarah M. Eden or historical romance will absolutely enjoy this book.

Thank you NetGalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing the ARC. This review and opinions are my own.

***I received a free copy of this ebook from the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions and words here are my own, as always.***

Another page-turning race for the Penny Dreadful Society in and out of safe spaces, danger, hints of romance, and heroism in Victorian England—even if it took me a few chapters to jump into the story. And thank heaven Hollis got a chance to show his talents at last. He could stop worrying about feeling like a second-rate member.

As in book #1 of the Penny Dreadful Society series, the main tale is interwoven with two other serial Penny Dreadful tales—authored by two other characters of the book. These extra storylines add to the suspense and to the humor, which I appreciate, and move the plot along nicely. I frankly can’t take too much tension without someone finally cracking a joke, even in a book, so the bit of humor in the penny dreadful story of Higginbottom’s School for Ghosts was very welcome.

I’m not a fan of people being in so much peril and danger—but I liked the book. Once I understood all three storylines and how they were working together, I finished it all in a rush.

This is seriously one of my favorite series! All of the characters are painted so vibrantly you can see them all in your head and the main ones I really would love to have as friends. Hollis' and Anna's story is one you can jump into right away. I loved that Anna is the thief, and that Hollis is the one that catches her. That was a fun twist (I mean, you know it by reading the back of the book, but I felt it was a novel idea). I loved getting the backstory for Hollis (as he was one of my favorites in the last book), and meeting Anna's family. I loved that Fletcher and the gang were all back, and I can't wait to see the other members of the Dread Penny Society get their own books as well.

The Gentleman and the Thief is a story that I read really quickly and couldn't put down. It is also a story that I will pick up again and again and enjoy it every time I reread it.

4.7 stars

I love almost every Eden novel and this one was on the list!!

We meet Hollis and Anna in the Lady and the Highwayman, and I’m very happy to have their story.

Hollis is a gentleman from a well to do family— who is dead broke and bankrupt. Hollis is having trouble with his brother tho and the Dream Penny Society to which he belongs to has issues as well. There has been some robberies and they have to find the thief before the authorities do.

The thief ? Anna, the woman Hollis has a crush on. Her midnight activities reveal a deadly underbelly that threatens all the good that the Penny Society is doing.

They need both Anna and Hollis to work together, with their own special skills to pull it off.

Ugh this was so good, they fell in love very organically and slow.

While the two POV plus the two dread penny stories is a lot, Kings story reflects the main plot and Hollis’s story gives more light to Hollis as a character and reveals a different side of him— the anonymity gives him more free to speak his mind and true thoughts than his status as a gentleman.

I also loved the card game scene. I won’t say more for spoilers but it’s my favorite part.

I initially had a hard time reading the beginning of the story. There was something with the introduction of the characters and the society in the story (maybe too many and new and am not sure their significance in the story ) that I had a hard time following the story. Then it finally took off, especially when I realized what the thief was doing and the reasoning behind. I did enjoy the budding love story between Ana and Hollis, especially after the realization of things. Then the case that followed and how they supported each other. It was an enticing read after it all made sense (to me) I recommend it

Fun book still dealing with the mysterious authors of penny dreadful stories. It was fun to read two such stories interspersed within the chapter itself. Still, I found it a bit confusing at first to try and keep track of four different storylines/POVs. I listened to the audio book, and I think I would have done better had I been reading it. The mystery and tension were good and well-paced. The romance was nice. Thanks to NetGalley and Shadow Mountain for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

The Gentleman and the Thief was a good one. Someone referred to it as charming and I must agree! I loved both Ana and Hollis, getting to know them bit by bit as the story moved forward - the revealing of their "shadier" sides was nicely done. Hollis was a big sweetheart and even though the romance didn't exactly sweep me off my feet, it was nice to see two people falling quietly and sweetly for each other.

I would have loved to know more about how Ana grew to be such a skilled thief - surely it's not something you learn just because you've had a rough time? She was a little bit too good at it without explanation for it to be "believable". Still, I enjoyed reading about a woman thief.

The stories in between the stories was a bit much, though. Sure, they were good, but not precisely necessary for the story.

Still, a nicely done story, not to be read by those looking for a firey romance, but those who wants a charming story about a thieving music teacher and an aristocrat who scandalously writes stories for the working class, with some action, mystery and good hearts.

/ Denise

I’m becoming a fan of this author book. This was good. Really enjoyed this story. I will read more. Go read. I love me a regency book.

A Penny Dreadful for their thoughts...

Book 2 of The Dread Penny Society series is about Ana and Hollis. Ana is trying to steal back things that were taken from her family when they were cheated out of their fortune. Hollis is a member of the Dread Penny Society who is tasked with finding the thief.

The story once again weaves the Penny Dreadful stories inbetween the main story’s chapters, I found myself skimming them to get back to the main one, then I went back as I preferred to read them after I finished the book.

Ana is very sympathetic, & I enjoyed Hollis's sense of humor, and it was very easy to root for them. I actually like this story even better than the first!

*Romance level: sweet kisses, nothing graphic

*Religion: Christian beliefs motivate many of the characters, but it’s not even remotely preachy

The Dead Penny Society is up to their old tricks and the streets of 1860’s London is all the safer for it!

In this instalment we follow the antics of the groups most aristocratic member, Hollis Darby as he investigate the thieving of the Phantom Fox and try to romance the lovely, yet reclusive Ana Newport, whom works as a music instructor.

While working on his investigation fro the Society , Hollis finds out that Ana has some special skills that he could use to help him, thus allowing for more time together. They soon learn that they have more in common than mutual acquaintances…

This was another delightful romantic mystery! I loved hove the characters lives intertwined without them know for so long! Both characters have plenty of secrets and like an onion, the secrets are slowly peeled away in this sweet tale.

Just like in the first book of the series, The Lady and the Highwayman, the inclusion of Penny Dreadful stories woven with the larger story aded to he the book on two levels. First, the stories were fun to read and would be a delight on their now, and second, the stories are front and centre to the characters in the book. They are reading and discussing them, so having the reader be in on the stories is a great addition!

This was another fun read, that I can easily recommend!

The Gentleman and the Thief by Sarah M. Eden is due to release November 3rd, 2020.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from Shadow Mountain Publishing through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

#TheGentlemanandtheThief #SarahMEden #NetGalley #pinkcowlandreads

The second installment of the Penny Dreadful Society Series, finds Hollis Darby smitten with music teacher, Ana Newport, a young woman from a society family that fell on hard times.

A fast paced romantic mystery with charming characters that blends Hollis and Ana's story along with the mysterious, and hilariously haunting tales of the Penny Dreadfuls. I especially loved the one about the human boy living in a school for ghosts!

This was such a fun read with great characters and stories within the story, I loved seeing characters from the previous book like Elizabeth and Fletcher. I can't wait to read the next book about Donnelly! Enjoyable and entertaining, a light-hearted read set in Victorian England.


I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Sarah M. Eden continues to be one of my favorite authors. Besides the main story, there are the Penny Dreadful stories throughout the book. What is fun, is that the characters themselves are "writing" the dreadfuls, which compliment the plot.

I received an ARC from Shadow Mountain.

The Gentleman and the Thief is yet another masterpiece from this talented author. I absolutely love this series of books. (Yes, I recommend you read them in order, you’ll appreciate characters more.) and the penny dreadfuls woven through the story are just as delightful as the main plot. This book has everything I love in a story, especially the little touches of humor and suspense. Ana and Hollis are fabulous. And, as always, it’s some side characters that steal the show. In this book, Very Merry. This author writes her books brilliantly and I appreciate the care she takes with the characters and details. I watched a video of her explaining how she plots these books and it is an amazing process.

This was a delightful story. I am really enjoying this entire series. Ana and Hollis are unique individuals and certainly a unique couple. I’m enjoying following the various other characters from previous books in the series and ones that have now been added through this one. I thoroughly enjoy Brogan and his Irish brogue, as well as his sister, which are both well narrated in the audible version. I look forward to updates on both the individuals and the couples from the stories so far, as well as more romance yet to come

This was a fun read really enjoyed it! Sarah always writes the best stories and family friendly always. loved the the plots, places and charcters

This is a quick, fun heist read that you won't be able to put down! Hollis Darby has the appearance of a well-bred society man, but he has a secret: his family is broke, and he's keeping himself afloat by writing Penny Dreadfuls. Ana has sworn to right the wrongs done to her family after her father lost his fortune and London Society shunned them. She is a music teacher by day, and a thief by night, reclaiming her family heirlooms from prominent houses around the city. Ana and Hollis are enlisted to solve a mystery and the two must team up. This book was a fast read, but very entertaining! I loved both of the characters and captivated by the romance and suspense between the two.

**Please see content/trigger warnings at the end of this review**

Hollis, a poor (but from a good family) man, who writes penny dreadfuls to stay afloat falls for Ana, a poor music teacher who moonlights as a thief at night. When a series of robberies start that are blamed on child thieves, Ana and Hollis decide to investigate. Hollis also belongs to a group of gentlemen (that also write penny dreadfuls) who are determined to make society better and are also on the case. When their investigation leads to a much bigger crime and illegal gambling rings, things start to get very complicated.

I would say all in all this book was fine. I couldn't really get into it, and I'm not sure if it was the pacing or the set-up, but nothing really popped for me. I was amused by the insertion of the penny dreadfuls that were being written by Hollis and one other gentleman (my favorite were the child ghosts). I wasn't sold on the reasoning for Ana's burglaries but I guess it leaves her with the moral high ground. The romance was chaste (both on and off-page) and there is a HEA.


**Content/trigger warnings: gambling, mistreatment of children, violence.**

I've really liked a few of Sarah's books before(especially Seeking Persephone) and I don't think it's a surprise that I ended up enjoying this one as well! We have a very sweet romance with two amazing characters who navigate class differences and other things along with the secrets that they're keeping from each other!

Initial Thoughts
I love historical novels and I read the first book in this series and really liked it. I was excited to give book 2 a try.

Some Things I Liked
Honestly, I read this one a while ago and it wasn't super memorable. I liked the historical banter, the time period, and the way that secret identities and writer were involved.

Series Value
I'd definitely keep reading this series and I think I could even see myself rereading the first two.

Final Thoughts
This is an enjoyable series. Not super memorable, but enjoyable nonetheless.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Sarah Eden doesn’t disappoint! I love and appreciate her grasp of history and the beautiful way she weaves it into stories.

I enjoyed the unique format of this one, but I felt like I never got as invested in the main storyline because of the stories from the Penny Dreadful series.

Historical romances are my favorite! To understand this one you really need to read the first one.
Many thanks to NetGalley for the ARC.

I think this is my favorite of the series so far! The romance part of the story was strong and wasn't overpowered by the mystery/thriller aspects (which I still enjoyed quite a bit). The characters are likable and relatable and the story of the overall series is moving along wonderfully.

I am eager to see what happens next!

This series of five books is complete. I had read #4 not long ago, but I’m so glad I took the chance to binge read the whole series in a week when I received the final ARC. You can read them as individual books, but the stories are so tightly interwoven that you really should get the whole five-story plot arc together.

And, while billed as “proper romance”, the romance is not, in my mind, the focus of the stories. There are mysteries to solve—each of the first four books lead us into the final showdown.

One common theme of this series is that everyone has a past that has made them who they are. For the most part, difficult pasts have led the focus characters to fight for right and to help the downtrodden, in a society that is still very much run by class.

We begin with a schoolmistress and a former street urchin turned author of “penny dreadfuls”, the lower-class literature that thrilled and entertained. But he’s also a member of a secret society of penny dreadful authors who fight crime (while sometimes committing a few crimes of their own in pursuit of the greater good).

We move on to a music teacher and a gentleman who also writes penny dreadfuls. Then to a bookseller/Russian émigré and an Irishman—again, a writer. And a doctor/writer and his secret wife, who comes from a crime family.

We end with the oddest pairing of all—a woman who committed murder and a police constable.

The mysteries are intriguing. As we learn more and more of the criminal mastermind, the fearsome Tempest, we also learn more of what makes our characters tick. The entire series plays out in a little over a year, and it is nice to be able to follow the aftermath of the prior books as each book moves along. Unlike some series romance, prior characters still play a part beyond name-dropping.

I especially looked forward to the final volume, as I wanted so much to know the why and the how of the formation of the Dread Penny Society. While this was explained, I felt like there could have been more. Likewise with the why of the Tempest’s quest for revenge, and why one particular traitor sold out the Dreadfuls.

I think the elements of intrigue were well-balanced with the romances. These were romances that were allowed to develop, based on admiration and companionship. Each had a reason why it might be impractical, but, despite danger and turmoil, love won the day.

There were many well-developed secondary characters in addition to the ten romantic leads. The street urchins, others of the Dreadfuls, family members—all added to the depth of worldbuilding.

As with other books published by Shadow Mountain, there is no cursing and the narration of the romantic interludes doesn’t progress beyond kissing.

One more note: Each of these books, in addition to the main narrative, contains two “penny dreadful” stories that parallel the main story. So Eden was really writing three stories every time!

Possible Objectionable Material:

Foul play, including thievery and murder, fighting, perilous situations, dishonesty, poverty.

Who Might Like These Books:

Fans of clean romance, Victorian London, mystery and adventure.

These books are also reviewed at https://biblioquacious.blogspot.com/2023/04/a-penny-dreadful-for-your-thoughts.html

Thank you to Shadow Mountain Publishing and NetGalley for providing ARCs of these books in exchange for my honest opinion.

Description- A gentleman scribes penny dreadful novels by night and falls in love with a woman who is a music teacher by day—and a thief at night.

LONDON 1865

From the moment Hollis Darby meets Ana Newport, he’s smitten. Even though he’s from a wealthy, established family and she isn’t, he wishes he could have a life with her by his side. But Hollis has a secret: the deep coffers that have kept his family afloat for generations are bare, so he supports himself by writing penny dreadfuls under a pseudonym. If not for the income from his novels, he would be broke.

Ana Newport also has a secret. Though she once had a place in society thanks to her father’s successful business, bankruptcy and scandal reduced his fortune to nothing more than a crumbling town house. So Ana teaches music during the day, and at night she assumes the identity of the “Phantom Fox.” She breaks into the homes of the wealthy to reclaim trinkets and treasures she feels were unjustly stolen from her family when they were struggling.

When Hollis’s brother needs to hire a music tutor for his daughter, Hollis recommends Ana, giving him a chance to spend time with her. Ana needs the income and is eager for the opportunity to get to know the enigmatic gentleman. What neither of them expects is how difficult it will be to keep their respective secrets from each other.

When a spree of robberies rocks the city, Ana and Hollis join forces to solve the crimes, discovering that working together deepens the affection between them. After all, who better to save the day than a gentleman and a thief?


I received this book to review by NetGalley before it came out, yes… I know it was a few years ago, but I DNF’d this book after the third attempt to read through it. I’m a mood reader, so I will take fault for being more into fantasy at this time than romance but it just wasn’t for me. Decent writing. Fun story.