In Madeleine Reiss's »The Taking of Irene Hart«, a riveting story unfolds against the backdrop of a secretive religious community in 1859 Somerset, England. At the heart of this historical novel lies a mother's fateful decision and its repercussions on her daughters, Ruby and Irene. The contrasting perspectives of these sisters offer a compelling exploration of faith, freedom, and the bonds of family.

As the plot progresses, we find ourselves immersed in the contrasting worlds of Ruby and Irene. The tenacious Ruby serves as a protective force, while the delicate Irene grapples with health issues that lead others to believe she possesses a mystical gift. With their mother falling deeper into the community's doctrines, Ruby senses something amiss, and her suspicions mount when a shocking revelation threatens their very souls.

Reiss skillfully crafts a world steeped in tension and mystery, transporting readers into an environment that feels both haunting and claustrophobic. Her evocative prose paints vivid images of the characters' psychological turmoil as they navigate the dark undercurrents of the community. The writing strikes a delicate balance between poetic beauty and urgent pacing, ensuring readers remain engrossed until the final page.

Through this gripping narrative, Reiss raises crucial questions about the potential dangers of blind faith and the struggle for personal autonomy in oppressive environments. Each character's journey is marked by emotional depth, particularly Hester's transformation from devout follower to disillusioned skeptic. As Ruby fights to protect her sister, their plight serves as a testament to the power of familial love amidst chaos.

While some elements of the story may appear predictable, Reiss's meticulous attention to detail and rich character development elevate the novel beyond its conventional trappings. The emotional resonance of the characters' struggles remains long after the book is closed, marking »The Taking of Irene Hart« as a thought-provoking and powerful read.

Reiss deftly blends historical precision with captivating storytelling, offering a work that not only engages readers but also invites introspection on themes that continue to be relevant today.

»The Taking of Irene Hart« stands as a testament to Reiss's ability to craft narratives that entertain and provoke in equal measure, solidifying her reputation as a talented and insightful storyteller.

3.5/5

This was a fascinating read based on a true story! I loved learning about the religious cult back in the Victorian times. Caught my attention and kept me reading.

As this is inspired by a true story I found it all the more fascinating and interesting. It's a historical drama set in the 1800's based around a cult. There's an abandoned baby to pull at your heartstrings. I thought it an intriguing plot which is enjoyable and entertaining.

Enjoyable Victorian historical fiction with a religious cult and a needy widow to kick things off. Sisters Ruby and Irene find themselves embroiled in the community run by the charismatic Peters but headstrong Ruby is not convinced. It’s a light read with some gruesome bits and I thought the policeman investigating a foundling baby gave the story more dimensions, my favourite character.

Set in 1859 Somerset, The Taking of Irene Hart by Madeleine Reiss is a compelling tale of familial bonds, desperation, and the perilous allure of blind faith. Loosely based on historical events, the book delves into the lives of the Hart family as they navigate the confines of a secretive religious community, where salvation comes at a price.

The story begins with Hester Hart, a widow struggling to cope with the devastating loss of her husband. In a modern context, her mental state might have been treated with professional support, but in the mid-19th century, such help was unavailable. Her daughters, headstrong Ruby and fragile Irene, initially welcome Hester’s renewed purpose, only to discover the ominous consequences when she signs over all the family’s possessions to a charismatic preacher, Reverend Peters. In doing so, she unwittingly entangles them in a cult-like community governed by sinister rules and a twisted philosophy.

Irene, plagued by seizures and visions of the future, is revered by the group for her supposed second sight. Ruby, ever the sceptic, is the only one who recognises the darkness lurking behind Reverend Peters’ facade. As Irene and Hester fall deeper under his spell, Ruby’s frustration and fear mount, forcing her to take on the immense responsibility of protecting her sister.

Reiss crafts her characters with depth and authenticity. Hester’s vulnerability and blind devotion are infuriating yet heartbreakingly understandable. Ruby, though flawed and impulsive, is a vividly realistic protagonist whose bravery anchors the story. Irene, with her delicate health and spiritual burden, is a poignant figure caught in a dangerous web.

The book explores darker themes, including manipulation, control, and the lengths people go to for acceptance and belonging. The sense of unease grows as the narrative progresses, and while the early chapters are slow-burning, the tension builds to a gripping climax. The vivid portrayal of the cult's oppressive atmosphere and its impact on the Hart family keeps readers hooked, even as frustration with Hester's decisions mounts.

The Taking of Irene Hart is not just a tale of suspense; it’s also a poignant exploration of familial love, resilience, and the consequences of misplaced trust. Reiss’ evocative writing and rich historical detail make this an unforgettable read for fans of historical fiction with a psychological edge.

Read more at The Secret Book Review.

This one kept me on the edge of my seat! The eerie, cultish atmosphere is perfectly done. The tension between the family dynamics, Ruby’s sharp instincts, and the slowly unraveling dark secrets makes this a gripping, emotional ride. It’s a paragon of historical fiction, and I was hooked from start to finish.